I've seen all of the movie except for "Hugo" and "Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close". I want to see those two movies before I dismiss the nominees completely as being another weak Oscar field. So far there is not one movie that you can point to and say that it defined movies in 2012, but most of the nominees that I've seen so far were at least enjoyable. Robert, I largely agree with how you have them ranked. I'm no student of film, but here's how I list them so far:The Tree of Life - It's a film that I was absorbed in right away. I'm a child of the 80's not the 50's, but it still evoked those feelings of growing up in middletown America, love, family, relationships, and the inherent beauty in reality.The Descendants - I want to hear someone's impression who hasn't been to Kauai or Hawaii. I think a big part of my love for this movie is it's gorgeous scenery. It deals with death and infidelity, which are two subjects that most people have to deal with on some scale so it was interesting to wonder how I would have handled the situations from various character perspectives.Midnight in Paris - It's a fresh script and Owen Wilson is great in it. Moneyball - Moneyball disappointed me. I've already done a short review in the Moneyball thread. My dislike has a lot to do with the baseball inaccuracies and building this into more of a Hollywood story in the end.The Artist - I liked this as a love story, except that in the end nobody truly falls in love. A lot of the movie was predictable, including the ending. I guess its a good emulation of the silent genre, but I wish they would have tried something more daring.War Horse - OK, I was moved, but more in a "Movie of the Week" sort of way. Gather the kids and sit down and enjoy this one.The Help - Robert, your summary is good. When I got to the scene with the lawn full of "commodes" I started wondering if they should have played the movie a little bit more seriously.I'm glad "Drive" didn't get nominated. That movie proved to me that there is sometimes a fine line between genius and complete garbage. The movie had so much potential, but continued to go nowhere. I did however really enjoy "Ides of March", but maybe only because it's an election year. Rango is really good too. I can't wait to see the rest of the nominees!