I think we have to be a little careful with applying "average situation" type analysis in that specific game. To play devil's advocate: Santana is pretty much the most unaverage pitcher in the league right now and Sheets isn't too bad himself. That means the run expectency for that game was significantly below average, probably a solid couple of runs less, which is huge. That makes small ball strategy much more appealing in certain situations. With regard to the 1st inning situation: 0-0, Weeks at 2B, Kapler AB, no out Despite Kapler's insanely good start, he should still be considered significantly below average hitter. Presuming a successful sacrifice, the odds of scoring at least 1 run does go up marginally against an average pitcher/defense.. not sure if that also applies against a pitcher like Santana. Is Kapler a good bunter? Doesn't look like he has very many sacrifices in his career, so I'd be tempted to say no. I still don't think I would have called for it but there are far worse situations that you could call a sacrifice in.