I was the first poster in this topic (reply #3) to state it's unlikely Casey will repeat his 2009 offense, so let me be clear on where I stand. I'm not cheering against the guy. Probably my favorite aspect of the game is when these career minor leaguers finally get a chance and make the most of it. In that regard, Casey's season was the story of the year for me. But you have to be realistic. Doug has always been great at finding these waiver wire/ freely available players. Brady Clark, Pods, Helms, Gintner, Turnbow, they all broke through and had at least a couple good years. Then, inevitably they fade away or find their way playing off the bench as journeymen for a few years. There's no shame in that. I believe there are lots of minor leaguers capable of playing in the majors if they only got their shot. Casey minor league career compares closely to these guys, not to some near All Star caliber 3rd baseman, which is kinda the way he hit last year. Maybe he truly has broken out; if so, I'm all for it. But to assume he's going to play like he did in 2009 for years to come is to assume he will defy the odds in a big way. It's been done before, but counting on it happening again is not a good plan.