1) Kotsay on the roster wouldn't be terrible as long as he never saw the field. At best, having him on the roster is a waste of a spot that could be used on somebody at least mildly productive. Starting Kotsay over Morgan against RHP's is horrible. 2) Nieves I won't fight that hard against, Kottaras is not clearly better, although I would probably go with Kottaras. 3) Even in this lineup, there is no way Gomez should hit second. 4) Betancourt is mostly on Melvin, but why not start Counsell 3 times a week at SS? 5) Don't be surprised.