I'd argue the 2nd set isn't quite as clear. Set one I'd go B, C, A...seems relatively obvious. Set two is less obvious, but I personally like C, A, B. For me B is a distant 3rd. A has more K's and slightly better whip than C...but significantly more runs allowed. Depending on what stats matter more, C and A are up for debate and generally pretty close. Agree with you that this year's crop is a lot closer. For me C takes it over A because ultimately I value the 14 less runs over the the 30 extra strikeouts, 5 extra innings & slightly lower rate of baserunners.