Pineda incresed his value just as much over the course of the 2011 season as Lawrie did, though. Both had questions coming into the season which they both answered and then some. As for not making the playoffs with Pineda versus Marcum, their production was pretty close to identical. Pineda had slightly less innings but was slightly more effective in the innings he threw. And as TooLive pointed out, they both tired towards the end of the season so that's a wash. My preference all along would have been to (one) not trade Lawrie since he was the last impact bat we had on the farm, (two) trade him for a pitcher with comparable talent/service time, (three) what happened. Don't get me wrong, last year was a blast all the way around but I think it could have all still happened with Pineda in place of Marcum and we'd be better off for the future.