Gutekunst has been the GM 7 seasons now since January of 2018. How many All-Pro players has he drafted? One. Jaire Alexander. How many pro-bowl players (and I don’t know if that even means anything anymore) has Gutekunst drafted? Three. Alexander, Jenkins and Gary.
Thompson, by comparison, was GM for 12 seasons and drafted a HoFer in Rodgers, a likely HoFer in Davante Adams and multiple All Pros: Clay Matthews, Jordy Nelson, and David Bakhtiari. Thompson also drafted a plethora of Pro Bowl players. (Bakhtiari probably was on a HoF path too until ripping up his knee).
Viewed through that prism, the Packers are not drafting as well as they have historically. However, Rodgers was so skilled he could paper over a lot of their shortcomings in talent in the regular season until it usually caught up with them in the playoffs. Without Rodgers’ ability to beat many teams almost single-handedly they’re a fringe playoff team in their conference.
Thus, why shouldn’t Gutekunst be shown the door? What has he really assembled in Green Bay? A handful of really good but not great players, and Micah Parsons. And he paid dearly for Parsons in terms of cap space and picks.