The difference is that Manny, Pujols, and Ortiz were all born in the Dominican Repulic. I have no problem with a US citizen player who also happens to have been born and/or is a citizen of another country playing for that country. However, for a guy to play for Italy or the Netherlands or wherever just purely based on his grandparents having ties to that country is a bit of a stretch if you ask me. Yeah, but then if all those guys basically had to play for the US, the US team would probably win handily, and the same people would complain that the thing is a pointless joke because of lack of competition. Can't have it both ways. I'd rather see the US and other countries that actually have baseball talent have multiple teams (maybe an east and west team - kinda like they do in Little League). This would be better than forcing some sort of fake team from Italy or Germany or wherever.