Kirby Puckett played 12 years total, ages 24-35. WAR 44.8, two WS rings, .318/.360/.477, 124 OPS+. Michael Young has 12 years so far, ages 23-34. WAR 26.9, two WS losses, .304/.350/.451, 106 OPS+ Unless Michael Young becomes Barry Bonds and suddenly gets better at the end of his career, there's no way he gets in. (Note: I don't care about WS results in HOF and this doesn't take into affect defense. But we all know that this is how the voters will look at it.)