C= Brewers edge Carson Kelly has been really good this year but William Contreras has been a top 3 mlb catcher for a while now.
1B=Very slight edge Cubs Andrew Vaughn has been a godsend but Michael Busch had an amazing year and as much as I want to call this a wash I can't
2B=Wash Turang and Hoerner are very similar players, Turang's 2nd half power burst gives him a bit more upside in a playoff series, but too close to call.
SS= Cubs edge Swanson had a 20/20 season despite the a .244 aveage and .300 obp. Both play good defense but Swanson is getting the big bucks for a reason (4.5 WAR)
3B=Wash Durbin and Shaw both had 3 WAR rookie years, Durbin's triple slash is a bit better but Shaw has a little higher potential
OF=Cubs Edge PCA, Tucker, and Happ is about as good of an OF as there is I would say Frelick and Chourio can be at PCA and Happ's level but the gap from Collins to Tucker is pretty big
DH=Brewers Edge Susuki started off really strong and has faded some, Yeli had the opposite season rough 1st 50-60 games and strong after that.
SP=Edge Brewers There are some big variables here with the health of Woody, Quintana, and Cade Horton (I think out the series), however Freddy and Priester should have a healthy advantage over Boyd and Imagana and it is a wash after that for me
RP=Edge Brewers Again the health/rustiness of Megill will play a big factor in this series. The Cubs bullpen of Palencia, Keller, Theilbar, and Pomeranz has been really good for them but I am not really worried about that group taking over the series where as Megill, Uribe, Koenig, and Ashby can with Misi as an extra wild card.