In what world is giving up Sal/Mitchell, Wichrowski, and Shane Smith giving up less than Herrera, Hunt, and Boeve. Saying Herrera has electric stuff makes me think you don’t know who he is. KC Hunt is at best comparable to a guy like Shane Smith so if you think KC Hunt is pretty damn interesting I don’t know how you wouldn’t think the same of Smith who is 3 months older and pitching extremely well in AA.
Anderson’s track record isn’t good. He’s had two good seasons in his career and one was in 2016. He's the biggest FIP overperformer among qualified pitchers, his xFIP and SIERA are both over 5, he’s making 2 times as much money as Fedde. Giving up a haul for him just for him to regress in Milwaukee while being our third most expensive player on the roster would be such a bad move.