I think the fact is, at the end of the season, the Brewers will have a bit of a surplus of infielders. They will need to deal from that position of strength if they will have any hope of acquiring quality starting pitching for next season. McGehee makes sense to deal, because he probably has a lower upside than a player like Gamel or Weeks and may be more of a health risk (I guess Weeks arguably could be, though). I'm not gung ho about trading him, due to the great year he's been having, but if you can deal him for a decent starting pitcher, I don't think there's any real question that Melvin would have to pull the trigger at that point.