Overbay DFA'd...will we show interest?

[Hate those Rodents]

He'd be a nice bat for the bench. I know Gamel may make him redundant, but if we really have no faith in Mat as a bench bat option, Lyle could be a guy we look at. I just don't see how he fits though.

[PrinceEatMeat]

Nope. That is all.

[KCBrewerfan34]

I would take a shot at minimum. You could let Wilson go. He would be our best bat off the bench, although some like Kotsay.

[jmeks23]

If he was RHH it would be better because he could give you a little slugging % off the bench but he's not so he's pointless considering they'll never relinquish Kotsay of his duties.

[dadofandrew]

If he'd agree to go to Nashville for a month, I'd promise him a call up in September. After he clears waivers, at the minimum of course.

 

Lyle might have to go to Huntsville for August, given younger prospects at AAA.

[RockCoCougars]

This is mildly surprising. Is Lee much of an upgrade at first? As for the Brewers, I don't really see a spot for him. As others say, if he's still around in a few weeks, I'd give him a minor league deal with the promise of a call up on 9/1. He'd be a decent PH guy down the stretch. I think he can probably do better though.

[JohnBriggs12]

I'd rather trade for Matsui, Giambi or Thome to be that late inning threat off the bench.

[bucksman4]

I can already see the Miller Park faithful holding their arms over there heads in the shape we all knew and loved..."OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!"

[Warning Track Power]

I'd rather trade for Matsui, Giambi or Thome to be that late inning threat off the bench.

Overbay, Thome or Giambi would be nice and a HUGE upgrade but I think any addition to replace Kotsay would have to almost certainly have the ability to play the OF. This pretty much limits it to Matsui or someone of his ilk.

 

[bucksman4]

Face it (because I have), for whatever reason Melvin and RR love Kotsay and Counsell's "veteran presence" in the clubhouse and forget that neither of them are good baseball players anymore. So, they forsake having the best players on the team that they can to keep their 'gritty' vets who can't hit worth a lick.

[GAME05]

there's no versatility with Overbay, and the only way Fielder is going to take a day off is if he's chained in his home. i'd like him off the bench, but for the amount of playing time he'd see, there's really no point in picking him up.

[brwrsfan]

He'd be more useful currently than Tim Dillard. Overbay could at least PH on a regular basis and could play 1b if we needed him too in a pinch.

[Hate those Rodents]

Overbay has just been released by Pittsburgh after being DFA'd several days ago. Pittsburgh will owe him his full 5 million this year and he can sign with anyone for just the minimum now. Has he played sporadically at a corner OF spot? Heck, Josh Wilson was able to do it. I'd like to get his bat on our bench for the minimum if we can somehow have it make sense...

[nate82]

I'd like to get his bat on our bench for the minimum if we can somehow have it make sense...

What bat? If he were to replace Counsell sure that would be OK but anyone else no thanks. Overbay can play 1B and that is it and I will take Kotsay over Overbay. At least Kotsay can play in the OF while Overbay can not.

[logan82]

At least Kotsay can play in the OF while Overbay can not.

 

Overbay could probably match the "defense" Kotsay brings.

[nate82]

Overbay could probably match the "defense" Kotsay brings.

I highly doubt that.

[JohnBriggs12]

Overbay could probably match the "defense" Kotsay brings.

I highly doubt that.

I'd take Kotsay's offense and defense over Overbay's at any position. Overbay hasn't had more than 70 RBI in a season since 2006. He's probably home counting the money he "earned" which was a lot for a guy as non productive as Overbay.

[rluzinski]

Overbay could probably match the "defense" Kotsay brings.

I highly doubt that.

I'd take Kotsay's offense and defense over Overbay's at any position. Overbay hasn't had more than 70 RBI in a season since 2006. He's probably home counting the money he "earned" which was a lot for a guy as non productive as Overbay.

ZiPS ROS Projection:[/b]

Overbay: .243/.325/.404

Kotsay: .259/.307/.370

I would prefer Overbay as a pinch hitter or at first base. I would prefer neither play the outfield for the Brewers.

[Harold Hutchison]

Overbay has just been released by Pittsburgh after being DFA'd several days ago. Pittsburgh will owe him his full 5 million this year and he can sign with anyone for just the minimum now. Has he played sporadically at a corner OF spot? Heck, Josh Wilson was able to do it. I'd like to get his bat on our bench for the minimum if we can somehow have it make sense...

Not in the majors, but in the minors, he had 5 games in the outfield (exact spot unknown) with Missoula, and 25 games in the outfield in El Paso (exact position unknown).

 

He's played, but the El Paso time is his most recent, and that was in `01.

[gregmag]

I'd take Kotsay's offense and defense over Overbay's at any position. Overbay hasn't had more than 70 RBI in a season since 2006. He's probably home counting the money he "earned" which was a lot for a guy as non productive as Overbay.

But Kotsay hasn't had more than 70 RBI in a season since 2005, so Overbay is better.

 

 

[monty57]

Counsell now has two hits in the past week and Kotsay had an RBI in the first inning yesterday while filling in for Braun (and of course hitting #3), so they're all but cemented onto the roster. If we added a Morneau-type bat off the bench, he'd be our 3rd PH option.

 

Kidding aside, I highly doubt we touch Overbay. God forbid something happen to Fielder, I'd rather have Gamel called up.

[djoctagone]

he's available again. designated for assignment by the diamondbacks.

[RWeeksFan23]

Kinda weird they DFA'd him, he's having a solid year for them.

[adambr2]

I'd bring him back just for nostalgic purposes, but we have absolutely no need for a 1B only player with Corey's emergence.

[brwrsfan]

In a contending year, I'd say yes as he is likely better than Ishikawa. On this team....not so much.