Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted
9 hours ago, BrewerFan said:

When?

He's come up, gotten sporadic playing time and he's had good at bats and played well... albeit in VERY small sample sizes... so I wouldn't use those are a ringing endorsement, but I don't see how you can say he's had his opportunities and didn't succeed with them. 

Yeah, I think a lot of fans will forever have an anchoring bias when it comes to Black. He was a good prospect that came up and didn't flash in his first small trial and that's what will be remembered. Add that to the fact we have some really nice prospects in the pipeline and that Black hasn't torn up AAA pitching and he is the "waste of a 40 man spot", etc to many. 

I would bet decent money that if most were asked to recite Black's MLB stats from the last few seasons they would be incorrect. Super small sample sizes but his 2024 call up is what they remember. In the last 2 years though he has only gotten 41 PA with us at the MLB level and has reached safely in 17 of those. 11/35 at the plate with 5 XBH. That's a really good 2 week stretch for most hitters.

I wouldn't bet on him being here either when the season starts... but he will get MLB at bats somewhere and a Garrett Cooper 2.0 situation is more than plausible.

  • Like 1
Verified Member
Posted
7 minutes ago, liveforoctober said:

Yeah, I think a lot of fans will forever have an anchoring bias when it comes to Black. He was a good prospect that came up and didn't flash in his first small trial and that's what will be remembered. Add that to the fact we have some really nice prospects in the pipeline and that Black hasn't torn up AAA pitching and he is the "waste of a 40 man spot", etc to many. 

I would bet decent money that if most were asked to recite Black's MLB stats from the last few seasons they would be incorrect. Super small sample sizes but his 2024 call up is what they remember. In the last 2 years though he has only gotten 41 PA with us at the MLB level and has reached safely in 17 of those. 11/35 at the plate with 5 XBH. That's a really good 2 week stretch for most hitters.

I wouldn't bet on him being here either when the season starts... but he will get MLB at bats somewhere and a Garrett Cooper 2.0 situation is more than plausible.

Black’s offensive game isn’t strong enough to make up for his lack of defense for this team, a team that values defense as much or more than any team in baseball.

Just isn’t a MKE Brewers-type of baseball player.

  • Like 2
Posted
1 minute ago, SF70 said:

Black’s offensive game isn’t strong enough to make up for his lack of defense for this team, a team that values defense as much or more than any team in baseball.

Just isn’t a MKE Brewers-type of baseball player.

I don't disagree. I just think he will be unfairly remembered.

But that happens a lot. Mike Boeve might be an after thought non prospect when we look back in years. He can really hit but injuries might never let him show it at the MLB level and it's unfortunate. Dylan O'Rae might never get a chance here and who knows if he does elsewhere ... but he is a really good ball player, etc. Happens all the time - still unfortunate for the guys who are mislabeled or never get the chance to be labeled.

Community Moderator
Posted
13 hours ago, BrewerFan said:

When?

He's come up, gotten sporadic playing time and he's had good at bats and played well... albeit in VERY small sample sizes... so I wouldn't use those are a ringing endorsement, but I don't see how you can say he's had his opportunities and didn't succeed with them. 

I agree that he didn't get much of a chance in 2025-26, but he had some consistent playing time while he was up in 2024 and he looked terrible.  The unfortunate part of being on a championship caliber team with other options at your position... if can't play D, you better be able to hit.  Then he really didn't do himself any favors at AAA the last two years either.  

Maybe he will go somewhere else and rake?  Who knows.  

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted
5 hours ago, CheezWizHed said:

I agree that he didn't get much of a chance in 2025-26, but he had some consistent playing time while he was up in 2024 and he looked terrible.  The unfortunate part of being on a championship caliber team with other options at your position... if can't play D, you better be able to hit.  Then he really didn't do himself any favors at AAA the last two years either.  

Maybe he will go somewhere else and rake?  Who knows.  

He got 58 PAs spread across the 2024 season. He was up for less than 10 days 3 times spread across the season. 

How about the 47 PAs he subsequently got where he hit .314/.415/.457 872 OPS.

I don't find that particularly useful, but if we're going to say he got his chance in '24... seems odd we're ignoring '25 and '26.

He's a LHed 1B/corner OFer. He may get his chance in Milwaukee if Bauers turns down the QO. 

  • Like 3

.

Community Moderator
Posted
1 hour ago, BrewerFan said:

He got 58 PAs spread across the 2024 season. He was up for less than 10 days 3 times spread across the season. 

How about the 47 PAs he subsequently got where he hit .314/.415/.457 872 OPS.

I don't find that particularly useful, but if we're going to say he got his chance in '24... seems odd we're ignoring '25 and '26.

He's a LHed 1B/corner OFer. He may get his chance in Milwaukee if Bauers turns down the QO. 

I'm pretty certain I didn't... Might want to read my post again? Yes, he hit well in a handful of ABs... that is why I said it was odd he didn't get more of a chance. 

Elsewhere, I also mention that it's pretty obvious from the way they are using/handling him that he isn't in their main plans.  If Bauers declines the QO, I can see Black having a chance for a couple of months... but they certainly prioritize Burke over Black. 

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted

Black did great in his 2026 2 week stint, people pointed to “lucky” hits but who cares. Had some deep doubles too. Spring training doesn’t mean much but he was absolutely raking and led MKE in RBIs despite playing 5-10 less games than the other players before heading to play for Team Canada in the WBC. He had an underwhelming season in AAA however. 

His lack of defense limits him for sure and I agree it’s likely he’s not in their plans going forward especially being out of options. Only chance is if Bauers hits FA and even then they might just trade Black away and find a different LHB 1B option. I do find it strange they’ve kept him on the 40 man for years now despite not wanting to give him a long term chance. I guess maybe they just liked having him as an AAA insurance guy in case Yelich or Bauers got hurt, which does happen every year at some point so it makes sense and a Yelich injury was the reason for his 2026 call up.

I saw someone on X suggest Kyle Manzardo from Cleveland as an inexpensive short term trade candidate to replace Bauers

Posted
9 hours ago, liveforoctober said:

Yeah, I think a lot of fans will forever have an anchoring bias when it comes to Black. He was a good prospect that came up and didn't flash in his first small trial and that's what will be remembered. Add that to the fact we have some really nice prospects in the pipeline and that Black hasn't torn up AAA pitching and he is the "waste of a 40 man spot", etc to many. 

I would bet decent money that if most were asked to recite Black's MLB stats from the last few seasons they would be incorrect. Super small sample sizes but his 2024 call up is what they remember. In the last 2 years though he has only gotten 41 PA with us at the MLB level and has reached safely in 17 of those. 11/35 at the plate with 5 XBH. That's a really good 2 week stretch for most hitters.

I wouldn't bet on him being here either when the season starts... but he will get MLB at bats somewhere and a Garrett Cooper 2.0 situation is more than plausible.

It's actually pretty funny how closely his career has tracked Bauers himself to this point.

You may be right, I think he's got a very narrow window to another opportunity with the Brewers, as I've said, it'd be if Bauers turns down the QO, you may give him the first shot to be in a platoon role. I don't think they are going to go out and spend much on a LHed 1B option otherwise and I don't know if Fischer can do the job. Burke... he's gotta slim down a bit. He's going to get too big. 

 

I just think he'll prove to be a good offensive player. I think it's pretty obvious he won't hit for Bauers type of power, but I could see a nice career as a utility player. 

  • Like 1

.

Posted
3 hours ago, CheezWizHed said:

I'm pretty certain I didn't... Might want to read my post again? Yes, he hit well in a handful of ABs... that is why I said it was odd he didn't get more of a chance. 

Elsewhere, I also mention that it's pretty obvious from the way they are using/handling him that he isn't in their main plans.  If Bauers declines the QO, I can see Black having a chance for a couple of months... but they certainly prioritize Burke over Black. 

I'm following along just fine... though I missed where you said it was odd he didn't get more of a chance.

I was responding to this part;
 

Quote

He has had his opportunities and didn't succeed with them. 

 

11 hours ago, CheezWizHed said:

I agree that he didn't get much of a chance in 2025-26, but he had some consistent playing time while he was up in 2024 and he looked terrible. 


He really did not look terrible though. He was up 3 times for about 10 days in 2024 at 23 years old and got inconsistent PAs. At no point has he ever gotten anything resembling a chance, nor has he gotten consistent playing time. Not in '23. But if we're saying he DID in '23, then we'd have to look at '26, this past year, the longest period he's been up.
He hit .333/.357/.481.

That was ~25% of his PAs.

So framing it as 'he got his opportunity and he failed,' which is paraphrasing, but I think an accurate representation of what you said... feels a bit lacking. 

If Bauers is back, he's likely gone. If he's not, I think he deserves the first look at 1B. If he's back, obviously he has a much more narrow avenue to playing time... but I would like to see him given an actual shot. 

  • Like 1

.

Community Moderator
Posted

My issue with Black is he hasn't been good at AAA. It's one thing to argue he just hasn't gotten a chance at the big league level (which is accurate), but shouldn't he at least be decent at AAA? It's hard to picture him somehow hitting MLB pitchers better.

  • Like 8
Posted
52 minutes ago, adambr2 said:

Most national news writers currently believe that Bauers is highly likely to reject the qualifying offer. 

And I don't blame him one bit.

but it's not like every guy suddenly forgot every piece of advice he gave
Posted
9 minutes ago, 82brewcrew82 said:

And I don't blame him one bit.

Nor do I, Nor do I have any issue with that from a Brewer fan perspective.

Our system is full of potential 1B options. Bauers is probably the biggest regression candidate on the team. We got what we needed out of him, and who would have thought we would get a 1st round comp pick for him on his way out.

The beat will go on without Bauers if he leaves, just like it went on without Burnes, Adames, Peralta, etc.

  • Like 4
  • Love 1
Posted
19 minutes ago, adambr2 said:

Nor do I, Nor do I have any issue with that from a Brewer fan perspective.

Our system is full of potential 1B options. Bauers is probably the biggest regression candidate on the team. We got what we needed out of him, and who would have thought we would get a 1st round comp pick for him on his way out.

The beat will go on without Bauers if he leaves, just like it went on without Burnes, Adames, Peralta, etc.

Take the 23 million he would’ve gotten… Add it to whatever we were preparing to offer Bill, and get it done with WC

Then use the first round pick to draft a high upside catcher to take over in 2030 or 2031

  • Like 3
Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 11:26 AM, adambr2 said:

Nor do I, Nor do I have any issue with that from a Brewer fan perspective.

Our system is full of potential 1B options. Bauers is probably the biggest regression candidate on the team. We got what we needed out of him, and who would have thought we would get a 1st round comp pick for him on his way out.

The beat will go on without Bauers if he leaves, just like it went on without Burnes, Adames, Peralta, etc.

And the beat went on without Craig Counsell also. 

 

Posted
2 minutes ago, Brian said:

And the beat went on without Craig Counsell also. 

 

Interesting thought experiment:

do the Brewers win the World Series in this era, in this year or any other year, if Counsell accepts the deal to stay with the Brewers -/ long term as many expected rather than go to the Cubs?

Posted
10 minutes ago, adambr2 said:

Interesting thought experiment:

do the Brewers win the World Series in this era, in this year or any other year, if Counsell accepts the deal to stay with the Brewers -/ long term as many expected rather than go to the Cubs?

Listen to No Way (No Way Jose) - Single by WWE | Spotify

Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 11:26 AM, adambr2 said:

Bauers is probably the biggest regression candidate on the team.

I actually don't think he is. Chase rate, hard hit rate, none of his performance this year suggests it was a fluke year. 

I'm... perfectly fine with the Brewers not matching this, glad we'll get an additional 1st rd pick... that's great. But I also don't think Bauers is a particularly big regression risk. I'm more worried about Contreras over the next 4-5 years and it sounds like we're much more interested in re-signing him, likely for more money per year. 

.

Posted
3 hours ago, adambr2 said:

Interesting thought experiment:

do the Brewers win the World Series in this era, in this year or any other year, if Counsell accepts the deal to stay with the Brewers -/ long term as many expected rather than go to the Cubs?

Pretty unpopular opinion, but... yeah, I do. 

It's not like Greg mismanaged games, we got just incredibly bad luck or sometimes weren't the best team. If Hader doesn't give up a couple big hits to Soto and Freeman we're advancing, if the hard hit balls vs the Dbacks were normalized, we advance that year. Williams gave up a 3R HR to Alanso... though, that might have been Murphy. Anyway, it just kinda speaks to the variance in the post-season. 
 

But... maybe. I know we won a World Series with the guy who stuck around... and Chicago hasn't. So I can talk myself into that version as well!

.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...