I think the Cespedes signing & trade for Smith indicates that Crisp isn't viewed as an important long-term piece, as well he shouldn't be. I'd have a hard time believing Beane is planning around getting PAs for Crisp. On Cespedes... people downplayed the level of competition in Cuba when the Reds signed Chapman, which seems to be working out alright for Cincy. It's not about what 'level' anyone thinks the Cuban league is at, it matters what your scouts have to say about whether or not the player will translate to MLB. Obviously the A's feel he will, at least enough to justify the pretty modest salary & contract they agreed upon to sign him. I mean, Brett Lawrie clearly wasn't ready for his delayed-by-wrist-injury promotion to the big-leagues in 2011, depending on who you asked. Then he came up & hit. The Jays were ready to make that promotion at the start of 2011 because he was ready, talent-wise, not because he'd done [X] at level [Y]. And if simply being near Manny is enough to significantly affect the development of young players, then the young players are your problem, not Manny Ramirez. It's like being upset that Melvin gave a NRI to Izturis because he can't hit, & will infect the other players with suckiness. I honestly don't really care one way or the other about Beane, I think he's a solid GM who receives too much praise & far too much criticism. I mean, yes, you can make a GM look bad by listing only the moves you don't agree with. But none of these you've listed are major, or really even matter, in the big picture. Big-picture-wise, Beane has been consistently building towards the A's contending once they get a new stadium. He's sold high pretty well recently on his pitchers who are in arbitration years (Cahill, Gonzalez, Breslow), and has helped build one of the better farm systems in MLB. John Sickels sums up the situation in Oakland nicely, in his '12 Top 20 Prospects feature: "This system was looking pretty thin until the flurry of trade activity this off-season. You now have the nucleus of a future starting rotation with Parker, Cole, Peacock, Gray, and possibly Milone, plus some staff-filling arms backing them up."