Yeah no the Badgers are not Northwestern right now they are better than them and by a lot. If the Badgers go back to someone like Leonhard they should just get out of the Big Ten and go to conference USA or something like that. The recruiting would return to PC levels of well we tried to get a 3-star recruit but we couldn't get them. We also tried for a 4-star recruit but we gave up after saying hi to them.
The HC that the Badgers should have kept was Bielema but the Wisconsin wasn't willing to pay the assistants enough. Which is the reason the Badgers have lost some good assistants.
So why wasn't Leonhard offered a HC position? The answer is obvious he didn't want to do the recruiting similar to PC. The changing of the offense wasn't good but the recruiting has been far better under Fickell than it ever was under PC. Again losing Bielema who was and is still able to recruit in the current environment.
You have to be able to recruit to be successful in college football. Leonhard wasn't going to do that. You can't win by getting in state 1-3 star players. I don't see how Leonhard would be any better than Fickell. Defensively maybe but offensively it would be the same boring run ball down the middle of the line play after play after play. There had to be a change and Leonhard wasn't going to change. They needed to go back to the Bielema offense where they actually did more than run straight down the middle. You see it at Illinois now with Bielema they do more than what Leonhard would have been comfortable with.
I hate this stupid it is Wisconsin football you have to run the ball and that is all you can do. It is just stupid.