Jump to content
Brewers and Tigers, join our game thread! ×
Brewer Fanatic

sveumrules

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    10,375

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    201

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Blogs

Events

News

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Top Prospects Ranking

Milwaukee Brewers Videos

2022 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

Milwaukee Brewers Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

2024 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks

The Milwaukee Brewers Players Project

2025 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Pick Tracker

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by sveumrules

  1. sveumrules
    Interesting idea as the Jays could use a boost at 3B/2B, though I don’t think Adames (+18 DRS | +17 OAA from 2021-23) on the eve of free agency would be the one moving off SS with Bichette at -9 DRS | -15 OAA over that same time frame. Only guy close to Adames (per BTV’s estimation anyway) that really makes sense is Alex Manoah. Would be a pretty huge risk given his implosion last year, but if he figured it out again that’s potentially four years of a TOR starter.
  2. sveumrules
    Welcome to the board. All things considered, best case scenario for Rhys would probably be to come out raking but have the Brewers be non-competitive and deal him at the deadline. That way he could opt out without a potential qualifying offer hanging over his head. If that scenario plays out, have to imagine the Brewers would want to get prospect(s) back that are at least equal in value to the comp pick they’d get with the QO.
  3. sveumrules
    You said “a bit behind” which doesn’t imply a huge difference at all. Charlie Greene and staff were able to coach up Narvaez, Contreras and Caratini on framing… Narvaez 16-19: -22.3 FRM 20-22: +20.2 FRM Contreras 20-22: -6.3 FRM 2023: +14.4 FRM Caratini 17-21: -5.0 FRM 22-23: +10.1 FRM Their CS% didn’t see quite the same level of improvement… Narvaez 16-19: 52/251 = 20.7 CS% 20-22: 47/218 = 21.6 CS% Contreras 20-22: 16/71 = 22.5 CS% 2023: 16/93 = 17.2 CS% Caratini 17-21: 30/142 = 21.1 CS% 22-23: 22/106 = 20.8 CS% Yes, A/A+ base runners aren’t as good at stealing bases as AA (or especially MLB) base runners are. Narvaez had a 25.0 CS% between AA-AAA, Contreras was at 32.7% in AA, Caratini was at 26% in AA. If you can only throw out 10.3% of AA base runners, MLB players will run wild.
  4. sveumrules
    I'd be fine with the offense as is, and running more of Yelich at DH with some combo of Mitchell/Wiemer getting the majority of the time at the other OF spot. Overall value wise it's probably close to a wash with a veteran DH providing a little more certainty and lineup depth versus Mitchell/Wiemer having a wider range of potential outcomes.
  5. sveumrules
    4/39 = 10.3 CS% 27/78 = 34.6 CS% If you legitimately believe this to be a just a bit of a difference, you need to recalibrate. If you understand the sheer magnitude of that difference and are just trying to undersell it, you are being openly disingenuous.
  6. sveumrules
    Spend Burnes money on a bat and could run out something like this… 1. Frelick RF (projected 103 wRC+) 2. Contreras C (projected 120 wRC+) 3. Yelich LF (projected 116 wRC+) 4. Hoskins 1B (projected 115 wRC+) 5. Soler (119) / Belt (106) / JDM (107) 6. Adames SS (projected 103 wRC+) 7. Black 3B (projected 104 wRC+) 8. Ortiz 2B (projected 100 wRC+) 9. Chourio CF (projected 93 wRC+) That’d be a pretty fun lineup.
  7. sveumrules
    Good thing the guy that made it works in NY now then.
  8. sveumrules
    Right, but there’s a gaping schism twixt “thin” or “full of question marks” and “worst rotations in recent history”. Corbin Burnes. chipped in 3.4 fWAR to a rotation that was 13th in MLB last year at 11.2 fWAR. The worst rotations in recent memory would be teams like 2022 WAS (-1.4 fWAR), 2023 OAK (1.1 fWAR), or 2021 CHC (2.1 fWAR). FanGraphs currently projects the Brewers rotation for 11.1 WAR in 2024. It would take an Rube Goldberg Machine of unfortunate events for the Brewers to end up with one of the worst rotations in recent history.
  9. sveumrules
    Vegas might not be the best prognosticator for the Brewers. 17 O/U: 70.5 17 wins: 86 (+15.5) 18 O/U: 83.5 18 wins: 95 (+11.5) 19 O/U: 86.5 19 wins: 89 (+2.5) 21 O/U: 83.5 21 wins: 95 (+11.5) 22 O/U: 90.5 22 wins: 86 (-3.5) 23 O/U: 85.5 23 wins: 92 (+6.5) Five out of the six last seasons they’ve been low on the Brewers, three of those by over ten wins. In aggregate they’ve undersold the Brewers by a total of 43 wins over the six full seasons of their recent competitive window.
  10. sveumrules
    Baseball America just gave the Brewers farm system their highest preseason ranking since 2004. This batch of prospects is right up there with the first wave of the Mark A era that kicked off our run of success from 2007-11 and the second wave that we’ve rode for the last seven years. The difference is all those highly ranked prospects are joining an already successful org, not one starting over from the dregs like they were with the previous two waves.
  11. sveumrules
    The 2018 team that went to G7 of the NLCS had a rotation of Jhoulys Chacin (35 GS), Chase Anderson (30 GS), Junior Guerra (26 GS), Brent Suter (18 GS), Wade Miley (17 GS), Freddy Peralta (14 GS) and Zach Davies (13 GS), with help down the stretch from Gio Gonzalez (5 GS) and Woody (4 GS). That rotation ranked 20th in MLB by fWAR and 15th by rWAR with the help of the 2nd ranked defense by DRS. SP is a question mark, no doubt, but the Brewers return a bullpen that paced MLB in Win Probability Added last year, a fielding unit that was again 2nd in Defensive Runs Saved, and an offense that should improve upon its 92 wRC+ from last year.
  12. sveumrules
    They’ve run franchise record payrolls in three of the last four full seasons - 2019, 2022 and 2023 with a global pandemic in the middle. Their OD payroll ranks have come in between 17th and 20th for the last five years in the 30th ranked market. Where do you believe they would need to rank to show an appropriate level of investment? They also have invested heavily in DR/VEN building a new academy and infrastructure from the ground up that has already started paying off with a guy like Uribe, Chourio up next (who got a pretty good investment from Mark A), then Quero, and Lara, etc. In 2018, 2022 and 2033 they won the division at 96, 95 and 92 wins. Their only Wild Card year they came in at 89 and would have knocked out the eventual WS champs if Hader got his outs. The team has always said they’re playing to win the division and have been pretty good at it. They won 86 in their down year.
  13. sveumrules
    Hader for Ruiz/Gasser/Rogers/Limet was panned pretty heavily. Many questioned giving up talented arms like Olson/Kelly for Norris/Bush at the very same deadline.
  14. sveumrules
    The odds of Hall and Ortiz (projected around 3 combined wins) outproducing Burnes (projected around 4.5 wins) are pretty low, though not absolute zero either. Crazier things have happened. If someone got out of a DeLorean before last season and said the only two things they knew about the 2023 Brewers were that the offense was going to crater from a 103 wRC+ (11th) the year before down to a 92 wRC+ (24th), and that Woodruff would get hurt and only throw 67 IP, I don’t think many would have predicted the Brewers adding six dubs onto their 2022 total and winning what was forecast as a tight division with relative ease. No matter how 2024 shakes out, this trade was made primarily for 2025 and beyond where Hall and Ortiz will hopefully be stacking wins compared to the absolute zero we’d surely be getting from Corbin at that point.
  15. sveumrules
    It’s kind of a short track record at only one season, but here’s how Arnold fared in his first year… The Good (13 players at +19.8 WAR) Contreras (5.4 WAR), Miley (3.4 rWAR), Payamps (1.8 rWAR), Wilson (1.4 rWAR), Rea (1.3 rWAR), Perkins (1.2 WAR), Peguero (1.0 rWAR), Canha (1.0 WAR), Miller (0.9 WAR), Teheran (0.8 rWAR), Santana (0.7 WAR), Anderson (0.5 WAR), Megill (0.4 rWAR) The Bad (6 players at -2.7 WAR) Winker (-0.8 WAR), Voit (-0.4 WAR), Singleton (-0.4 WAR), Chafin (-0.4 rWAR), Varland (-0.4 rWAR), Tapia (-0.3 WAR) Looks line Arnold came out about 17 wins ahead on his transactions last year.
  16. sveumrules
    This plan is essentially the same one the Brewers have been running since 2017, a seven season stretch during which they’ve won the 6th most games in MLB. Given the front office’s track record of knowing what they’re doing more often than not, combined with the highly ranked farm system they’ve assembled without the benefit of high draft picks, I feel pretty good about their odds of avoiding long term mediocrity or worse. The first wave way back in the day was all hitters and Yo, the second wave was all pitchers and Orlando. This next wave looks to have the best mix of both. The writing has been on the wall for the the end of this era since trade deadline 2022, bring on the new. I’m excited to see how exactly the wave crests or crashes.
  17. sveumrules
    ChatGPT needs help, Brewers went 7-12 in the postseason during the Burnes/Woody plus Freddy years. Sure, they’re only 1-9 over their last ten postseason games going back to Game 7 of the 2018 NLCS, but whatcha gonna do, even the mighty Dodgers are only 2-8 in their last ten postseason games. Same record as the small market ideal Rays over their last ten. For all their money the Yankees are 3-7, with all their devil magic the Cardinals are 1-9, (and neither even made it at all last year), heck, the best in baseball Braves are 2-6 since winning the 2021 WS.
  18. sveumrules
    ZiPS is currently showing Ortiz (1.8 WAR), Hall (1.1 WAR) and Burnes (4.4 WAR) on their FG player pages. Isn’t that more like 1.5 wins?
  19. sveumrules
    He was playing his age 24 season in 2023. He will be playing his age 25 season in 2024. Like purt near every player drafted before 2020, his development was delayed a full year by a global pandemic.
  20. sveumrules
    The Brewers are never well thought of. But they’ve made a regular habit of beating those prognostications over the last seven, eight years.
  21. sveumrules
    Because the Brewers FO thinks the sum total of all moves made so far (and maybe even some yet to be made) will allow them to remain competitive in 2024 while also increasing their chances of competing in 2025 and beyond.
  22. sveumrules
    Trade for Cease at $8M.
  23. sveumrules
    Getting Wilson, Rea and Perkins for free was another four wins for nothing.
  24. sveumrules
    Burnes last three years… 35.6 to 30.5 to 25.5 on K%. 5.2 to 6.4 to 8.4 on BB%. 0.38 to 1.02 to 1.02 on HR9. 1.63 to 3.14 to 3.81 on FIP. 2.43 to 2.94 to 3.39 on ERA. 6.3 to 5.3 to 4.8 on rWAR. 7.5 to 4.6 to 3:4 on fWAR. Corbin has regressed pretty hard two years in a row across the board with only one year of control remaining. That’s why Mayo has a higher surplus value on BTV and was always a pipedream.
  25. sveumrules
    Mitchell has pretty divergent splits so far in his limited professional career... MiLB (592 PA) 13.2 BB% | 25.5 K% | 60.7 GB% MLB (141 PA) 9.2 BB% | 38.3 K% | 38.9 GB% In the minors he has had a reasonable plate discipline profile and hit everything on the ground, in the majors his Ks have exploded and he's hit everything in the air. The main problem though (besides the ridiculously unsustainable .441 BABIP in the majors) is only 733 total PA over three full seasons.
×
×
  • Create New...