Just to clarify, that's according to baseball-reference's version of WAR, FanGraphs has it as the following: That said, while I'm rooting for a Burnes Cy Young, I can definitely see the case for Wheeler. However, I wonder what stats you'd have to add to Burnes' resume in an additional 48.1 IP to equal Wheeler's line. The "ugliness" of that line could make an interesting case one way or the other. Edit: To answer my own question, at least to some extent, I figured out the following stat line would get Burnes to Wheeler's numbers in terms of IP, ER, H, BB, HR, and Ks: 48.1 IP, 4.47 ERA, 1.26 WHIP, 3.17 K/9, 2.42 BB/9, 1.86 HR/9 So significantly worse than he's been, but the ERA/WHIP numbers aren't entirely implausible either.