The Man Goes On the Roster: Brandon Woodruff and the Non-Dilemma

[Matthew Trueblood]

Image courtesy of USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

It's all pretty fragile. It's all pretty turbid. There's no good way to know, really, whether Brandon Woodruff will be ready to get people out in the high-pressure, high-stakes environment of a World Series. He told reporters he felt very good about his bullpen session during the NLCS, and he told Curt Hogg of the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel (after the Brewers clinched their first National League pennant) that it would be hard to keep him off the World Series roster, but there's a good chance he's not actually ready to pitch at a high level. He admitted that he only took one brief glance at the data providing feedback during his mound session. He fought for the right to return to the active roster, earlier this season, even though his velocity was way down and he was clearly not back to full health.

To that, I say this: Who cares? It doesn't matter. It's very, very simple: the man goes on the roster. If Woodruff is upright; if his arm isn't in a sling; and if he believes he can help his team in even the smallest, most emergency-only way, he goes on the roster. Woodruff is the most respected veteran in the organization, above even newly minted captain Christian Yelich. He's the one guy the team has made big exceptions for. He's a symbol of what makes the team special, on several levels.

When Woodruff's shoulder gave way in September 2023, it didn't actually bring a sudden and premature end to the Brewers' season, but it felt like it. Losing their prospective Game 1 starter was one thing. Losing that guy and their leader and competitor-in-chief (all in one bundle) was another. It was particularly cruel and worrisome, too, because by the time the Brewers had been swept out of the postseason by the Diamondbacks, it was clear that Woodruff would need surgery and miss the entirety of 2024.

In fact, the injury was career-threatening, and worse still, it almost didn't matter whether he would eventually make it back or not. That 2024 season was to be Woodruff's last under team control, and only if the team elected to tender him a contract and absorb the high salary he would earn in his final year of arbitration eligibility—for a player who wouldn't take the field all season. Fat chance. Until he got hurt, there was much speculation about whether the team would trade Woodruff in the ensuing offseason, just as there was about Willy Adames.

Sure enough, the team non-tendered Woodruff later that fall. He nearly signed elsewhere. He nearly signed—perish the thought—with the Cubs, to whom Craig Counsell had defected in November. At the last moment, though, he and the Brewers fell back together, with Milwaukee getting him cheap in 2024 and a bit less cheap in 2025, when both sides hoped he might return.

Return he did, last summer, although it took longer than anyone hoped. At the start of spring training, there was chatter about whether he could be back in the rotation before the end of April. Ultimately, he wouldn't pitch for the big-league team until early July. He was phenomenal when he was on the mound, but heartbreakingly, his shoulder balked again late in the regular season, and he was unavailable for the playoffs again. His free agency rushed up to meet both parties again, and the Brewers faced another tough decision: whether to extend the qualifying offer.

Normally, this would be a no-brainer. The Brewers don't offer players $22 million and change when it's not clear that they can be high-end contributors, and it was not at all clear that Woodruff could be a high-end contributor. The shoulder felt like it was hanging by a thread. He'd lost 21 months to one injury, come back for not even three months, and suffered another. This time, he entered the offseason with a reasonable expectation of health and readiness for the following season, but the former workhorse would need to be handled with kid gloves. That's no way for a team on a tight budget to spend around 15% of its payroll.

Yet, the team gave him the QO. It was pretty clear he would accept it, but they gave it to him, anyway. For a second time, the organization made an exception where Woodruff is concerned, because (as a teammate and a competitor and as a performer) he's exceptional. A team like the Brewers doesn't dominate for one decade and stand in position to do so for another one without sticking to its rules, but no team succeeds if it can't spot the places where exceptions to strict rules are in order.

The rules that have made the Brewers great might dictate that they eschew putting Woodruff on the World Series roster. Twice this year, he suddenly lost velocity in alarming ways and had to be placed on the injured list. The last time we saw him, he was barely touching 90 miles per hour with his heater, and trending down.

Ordinarily, a team with as stringent and well-calibrated a set of best practices as any in the league wouldn't put that guy in position to have to pitch with the first championship in team history hanging in the balance. Then again, though, Woodruff had a 2.98 ERA even this year, and since coming back from the surgery last July, he's struck out roughly 30% of the batters he's faced and walked barely more than 5%. You can make a case that he belongs on the roster even through an objective lens, if his rehab has been going as well as he feels and if he looks good facing some live batters over the next few days.

But it shouldn't matter. This is not an ordinary situation, in the slightest. This is Brandon Woodruff. Besides, the Brewers haven't trusted Kyle Harrison or Chad Patrick enough to put them on the mound at all over the first two rounds of their playoff run. To put either of them on the roster and leave off Woodruff would be absurd. If Woodruff can pitch, the man goes on the roster. 

This World Series is not for funsies. It's not an exhibition. The Brewers should fight fiercely to win it. But this playoff run has been about redemption, and about completing a story the team left painfully unfinished in 2018, 2019, 2021, 2023, 2024 and 2025. It's been about the project this team began a decade ago to fruition. Only one player available to them next week was in organization a decade ago. Only one has been at the heart of it all, and even been its beating heart, at times. One player has the strongest ties of any player to the late Bob Uecker, and has already been the subject of multiple exceptions made to the rules that helped the Brewers get this far. One player represents this team's improbable and soul-stirring defiance of baseball's economic system and its very natural laws. If he can so much as fire one good strike in there, that man goes on the roster.

View full article

[keephopealive]

I'd put him, but only if he can pitch.  We didn't need Harrison or Patrick because the series was a 4 game sweep. No guarantee any series ends so quickly, and so they were insurance.  I would put Woodruff on and May off.  May has great stuff but has not shown he has the emotional/mental fortitude to succeed.  He only pitched well after the game seemed lost.  Patrick was great last year in the playoffs, and Harrison looked like he found his pitches in his last outing.  I'd just swap the two red-headed righties. 

[Rick Daltons Flamethrower]

 "The Brewers haven't trusted Kyle Harrison or Chad Patrick enough to put them on the mound at all over the first two rounds of their playoff run. To put either of them on the roster and leave off Woodruff would be absurd. If Woodruff can pitch, the man goes on the roster." -Matthew Trueblood-

I couldn't agree more.  ....... I would lean towards dropping Dustin May. He gave up the big bomb to Otahni. He did well on 10/12 vs LAD. His last 10 outings except for the 10/12/26 game is " "under mediocre". That is my ranking category based upon what I have been seeing. He seems wound up and on edge when I check out his eyes. Kind of like Craig Counsel chewing his finger nails.  Per Stat Muse he has a record of 1-1 with an ERA of 5.65 and 31 strikeouts in 10 appearances in his last 10 games. 

Long and the short of it is get Woody on the World Series roster. Appreciate the article!!!!!!!