Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted
21 minutes ago, nate82 said:

It doesn’t look like the owners are willing to budge on the salary cap.  

How bold of them on November 18th. Truly withstanding the pressure.

Posted
23 minutes ago, nate82 said:

It doesn’t look like the owners are willing to budge on the salary cap.  

No one is budging before December and probably not till February. Once a full season starts to be in jeopardy the goal posts will start to move inwards.

Posted

I think I'm the only person in Wisconsin who doesn't want a cap.

If the players ever did somehow agree to a cap, it would mean the owners gave up monumental concessions to the players, and just about all of them would be at the expense of well run teams like the Brewers. Quicker to free agency, quicker to Rule 5, Rule 5 options, standardized international facilities and rules, an international draft. The system that allows for the Brewers to be successful would be cratered. 

As nice as Milwaukee is in the summer, it'll absolutely never be a free agent destination when all other factors are equal. All a cap is going to do is increase the likelihood we lose our best players a year or two earlier because why sign a long term extension if you reach free agency in your mid-20s?

Posted

I'm 1000% FOR a cap, and mostly because it comes with a minimum spend which is ONLY good for brewers fans. That will force Mark A to either A. go big game hunting in FA frequently or B.(and most importantly) resigning guys like Turang and Contreras, and others as time goes on. How is that bad? 

Posted
16 minutes ago, ImissDougMelvin said:

I'm 1000% FOR a cap, and mostly because it comes with a minimum spend which is ONLY good for brewers fans. That will force Mark A to either A. go big game hunting in FA frequently or B.(and most importantly) resigning guys like Turang and Contreras, and others as time goes on. How is that bad? 

It’s worth remembering that even though signing aging veterans is expensive, aging veterans are also usually in the decline phase of their careers.

We should not aspire to acquire many aging veterans. The White Sox just committed $52 million to Dustin May. We should not want to feel forced to do that.

@Matt I also oppose a cap because it would make the game more mediocre like the NFL.

  • Like 1
Posted
13 minutes ago, ImissDougMelvin said:

I'm 1000% FOR a cap, and mostly because it comes with a minimum spend which is ONLY good for brewers fans. That will force Mark A to either A. go big game hunting in FA frequently or B.(and most importantly) resigning guys like Turang and Contreras, and others as time goes on. How is that bad? 

Because it’s not how this team builds WS winning rosters.

Elite prospect-procurement & elite prospect development with astute trades that allow for massive control over a mostly 22-30 year old roster has not only won one (1) WS title already but has created the best organization from top to bottom in all of baseball that’s going to lead to even more titles.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Signing old free agents is the quickest way to sink a team. The current system of indentured servitude for 10 years is perfect for a team like the Brewers. Obviously, because look at their record over the last decade. Can it even be argued against? 

Posted
1 hour ago, SF70 said:

Because it’s not how this team builds WS winning rosters.

Elite prospect-procurement & elite prospect development with astute trades that allow for massive control over a mostly 22-30 year old roster has not only won one (1) WS title already but has created the best organization from top to bottom in all of baseball that’s going to lead to even more titles.

 

 If they are required to spend a minimum of 180 mill. That changes things. What should be most frustrating to people is that obviously Mark A(who is on the negotiating committee for the owners), is apparently fine with raising the minimum to $180 mill(all owners are or they wouldn't be proposing it), which should make people wonder why the heck he hasn't been spending more then he has all these years, since you know he obviously can. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, ImissDougMelvin said:

 If they are required to spend a minimum of 180 mill. That changes things. What should be most frustrating to people is that obviously Mark A(who is on the negotiating committee for the owners), is apparently fine with raising the minimum to $180 mill(all owners are or they wouldn't be proposing it), which should make people wonder why the heck he hasn't been spending more then he has all these years, since you know he obviously can. 

Guys I'm just asking everyone to do a little reading on this. It is not $180M in payroll.

  • Like 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, jw5511986 said:

Guys I'm just asking everyone to do a little reading on this. It is not $180M in payroll.

Owners propose a hard $258.2 million salary cap and $180.2 million floor starting in 2028

Posted

isn't this really just a fight between owners(shouting competitive balance) wanting an instant increase in franchise valuation vs. the few superstars making hundreds of millions?

both sides are wrong

Bryce Harper doesn't care about a 10 year journeyman like Bauers.  just like the owners don't care if the Pirates/Reds ever have a chance to win

Posted
1 hour ago, ImissDougMelvin said:

Owners propose a hard $258.2 million salary cap and $180.2 million floor starting in 2028

I think the point is the $180 million floor includes benefits, pension contributions, insurance for players, etc. More than just salary.

 

Posted
58 minutes ago, da swedish german said:

isn't this really just a fight between owners(shouting competitive balance) wanting an instant increase in franchise valuation vs. the few superstars making hundreds of millions?

both sides are wrong

Bryce Harper doesn't care about a 10 year journeyman like Bauers.  just like the owners don't care if the Pirates/Reds ever have a chance to win

No, one side is wrong. The owners are the ones locking the players out. The players would be happy to keep going along with the current (and very successful) CBA until the end of time. This is ENTIRELY about franchise value, and making teams as profitable as possible. Not profitable. They already are, to an insane degree. This is about making franchises 3x, 5x, 10x their current worth, and to do that they have to control costs for prospective buyers. 

This has nothing to do with fair play or equal revenue sharing. That's the line the owners are feeding the general public because it plays well. Owners, especially modern owners with no ties to the local community, don't give a crap about winning. 

  • Like 1
Posted

The salary floor at 180 also includes media revenue sharing. Also why I don’t think a cap is happening. But I’d ignore anything out there, it’s all just posturing to try to get a semblance of narrative leverage on the other side. I expect when the dust settles it will be harsher luxury taxes and better mechanisms to actually enforce spending on those receiving revenue sharing to spend it.

  • Like 2
Posted

Maybe the smart teams would just spend their extra millions of dollars locking up all the young players vs signing some aging veterans who won't be worth their contract? That could be the new moneyball. Or maybe everyone does that and it remains a matter of how good of a talent evaluator you are in who you lock up and who you let go.

Posted
15 hours ago, Matt said:

I think I'm the only person in Wisconsin who doesn't want a cap.

If the players ever did somehow agree to a cap, it would mean the owners gave up monumental concessions to the players, and just about all of them would be at the expense of well run teams like the Brewers. Quicker to free agency, quicker to Rule 5, Rule 5 options, standardized international facilities and rules, an international draft. The system that allows for the Brewers to be successful would be cratered. 

As nice as Milwaukee is in the summer, it'll absolutely never be a free agent destination when all other factors are equal. All a cap is going to do is increase the likelihood we lose our best players a year or two earlier because why sign a long term extension if you reach free agency in your mid-20s?

I'm pretty dead set against a cap but the years of control on a young player become less important in a capped league. The Brewers value that control because it's literally how they are able to compete while still keeping salaries low. With a cap they'd have money to compete against all the other teams to sign them to extensions or once they hit free agency. I'm not going to pretend that having a cap is going to be an end to what the Brewers do, they'll just have to do it a little differently.

I like how the Brewers are operating their team, I hope it pays off in a couple two tree more World Series appearances in the short term. But I'm not going to fall victim to the thought that what the Brewers are doing is going to work from now to the end of time. The league is already showing signs of adjusting, it's the new moneyball and that was adjusted to also. The Brewers will need to keep finding success zigging while other teams zag.

My specific reasons for being against the cap is simply that I believe the players should be able to make whatever the market demands without restriction. I'm also not sold that a cap is going to be the huge boon to small market teams that everyone else does, the gap between the proposed floor and cap is still large enough to where big markets will still have a pretty hefty advantage when it comes to bidding on the best of the best free agents around the league. In essence, I'm not sure the landscape really changes that much and the Brewers will still need to grind to compete.

Posted
8 minutes ago, SeaBass said:

I'm pretty dead set against a cap but the years of control on a young player become less important in a capped league. The Brewers value that control because it's literally how they are able to compete while still keeping salaries low. With a cap they'd have money to compete against all the other teams to sign them to extensions or once they hit free agency. I'm not going to pretend that having a cap is going to be an end to what the Brewers do, they'll just have to do it a little differently.

I like how the Brewers are operating their team, I hope it pays off in a couple two tree more World Series appearances in the short term. But I'm not going to fall victim to the thought that what the Brewers are doing is going to work from now to the end of time. The league is already showing signs of adjusting, it's the new moneyball and that was adjusted to also. The Brewers will need to keep finding success zigging while other teams zag.

My specific reasons for being against the cap is simply that I believe the players should be able to make whatever the market demands without restriction. I'm also not sold that a cap is going to be the huge boon to small market teams that everyone else does, the gap between the proposed floor and cap is still large enough to where big markets will still have a pretty hefty advantage when it comes to bidding on the best of the best free agents around the league. In essence, I'm not sure the landscape really changes that much and the Brewers will still need to grind to compete.

The Brewers will maintain success for as long as their infrastructure remains elite, and that infrastructure is showing no signs of weakening.

Posted
1 minute ago, SF70 said:

The Brewers will maintain success for as long as their infrastructure remains elite, and that infrastructure is showing no signs of weakening.

I don't have much reason to doubt this but no team building method is infallible. Good teams go through cycles of greater success and lesser success.

Posted
16 hours ago, Matt said:

Signing old free agents is the quickest way to sink a team. The current system of indentured servitude for 10 years is perfect for a team like the Brewers. Obviously, because look at their record over the last decade. Can it even be argued against? 

The Brewers should not be used as an example, nor as proof of anything. The Brewers are a unicorn. One exceptionally successful small market team should not be used as proof the current system is fine. History doesn’t lie, small market are at a disadvantage. Some by choice, but many not by choice. Everyone could try tomorrow to be the Brewers and all of them would likely fail. They are truly on an all-time improbable success run in sports history.

It’s all fine and dandy to be okay with the current system because the Brewers are at the peak of their existence, but someday that will end. At which point not a single person on this board would like the current system.

  • Like 3
Posted
1 hour ago, SeaBass said:

I believe the players should be able to make whatever the market demands without restriction

But that is only tenable if all teams have the same money to spend, so either it's revenue sharing, or cap, or both, but otherwise it just means the team with crazy TV deals will get the best players.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Team Canada said:

But that is only tenable if all teams have the same money to spend, so either it's revenue sharing, or cap, or both, but otherwise it just means the team with crazy TV deals will get the best players.

No salary cap has historically worked with Premier league soccer. 🤷‍♂️

Posted
15 hours ago, ImissDougMelvin said:

 If they are required to spend a minimum of 180 mill. That changes things. What should be most frustrating to people is that obviously Mark A(who is on the negotiating committee for the owners), is apparently fine with raising the minimum to $180 mill(all owners are or they wouldn't be proposing it), which should make people wonder why the heck he hasn't been spending more then he has all these years, since you know he obviously can. 

You realize the owners are not going to let their own profit margins shrink right?  Higher payroll doesn't just mean bigger contracts for players.  It will come with increased prices for tickets, concessions, parking, etc. to make up the difference in profit.  Higher costs aren't absorbed by ownership, they are passed on to the customer.  When you combine that with the chance of fewer games, the cost to attend those fewer games is going to rise significantly.  

 

I think the Brewers are smart enough not to just throw money at old free agents just to meet a floor.  They will likely spend money on extending younger players, especially if the years of control also shrinks.  I am in the boat that is against the cap/floor because of all of the negative changes that will come with it.

Posted

To me more revenue sharing is the important part or real end goal.  Start with the cap threat just like they are, eventually meet in the middle with more revenue sharing on the TV deals. And sure increase more luxury tax penalties on the top end of salaries just like there is now, which chips in more on revenue sharing.   

If you need put a salary minimum in to get that so be it, although I don't think it needs to be at 150 mil.  But you can't let a team do what the pirate, marlin types have done to spend nothing, collect revenue share to profit and let your team be trash.  Something like 100 mil is enough.   The other big thing if I'm the players to target if they can't reduce team control is to simply increase what players get paid while under the rookie/arb salaries. They should be focused on helping the middle level players more rather than the few guys who get the mega deals

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...