Yeah, they’re just two different profiles.
Rooker is more boom or bust, both in terms of track record and plate discipline profile. I wouldn’t be surprised if he put up a 70 wRC+, a 130 wRC+ or anything in between over the next two months.
Canha is who he is at this point, a guy with a good idea what he’s doing at the plate, but not quite enough pop for a corner. Maybe he gets hot and puts up a 115 wRC+ for two months, but I also wouldn’t expect him to drop much below 90 either.
Its basically Hiura vs Cutch from last year.
I guess for me it seems like Canha would cost less to acquire just because he’s a rental, more expensive and has limited ceiling.
Rooker has way more questions about his future performance, but also more potential upside at a lower cost, which is why I think the A’s would want at least one interesting prospect for him.