Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted
Just now, adambr2 said:

My hope is that now they’ve gotten over the hump and won the World Series, the Brewers won’t feel as much urgency at trade deadlines to make a deal if only a bad deal is on the table. 

I think there’s something to that, maybe a little less pressure for the front office, especially being able to look back and pretty confidently say that the team you assembled in May, June, and July actually was indeed already good enough, even with the Dodgers getting Skubal. 

Have the Brewers ever felt that pressure/urgency? If they have they certainly have never acted on it.

  • Like 1
Posted
3 minutes ago, Lucas O. said:

Have the Brewers ever felt that pressure/urgency? If they have they certainly have never acted on it.

May and Romero for Frias and Ragsdale definitely felt like acting on it. 

  • Like 1
Posted
3 minutes ago, adambr2 said:

May and Romero for Frias and Ragsdale definitely felt like acting on it. 

Or they were really high on May and it just didn't work out they way they intended. Even if it was (which again is debatable) that's one time since the Stearns/Arnold FO took over that they have made aggressive moves at the deadline? 

  • Like 1
Posted
43 minutes ago, adambr2 said:

May and Romero for Frias and Ragsdale definitely felt like acting on it. 

I think they really thought May could be a gem. He completely sucked and some are way, way too generous evaluating his performance here. But I think the Brewers FO is way, way too smart to impulsively trade prospects for a meh player just to look like they were doing something. They wouldn't have done anything if they didn't really believe they were going to lab him into real production. 

  • Like 4
Posted
33 minutes ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

I think they really thought May could be a gem. He completely sucked and some are way, way too generous evaluating his performance here. But I think the Brewers FO is way, way too smart to impulsively trade prospects for a meh player just to look like they were doing something. They wouldn't have done anything if they didn't really believe they were going to lab him into real production. 

I agree with this take.  I think given some of his underlying stats, that they figured he could be an elite workforce for them down the stretch.

It did not happen that way, but luckily Henderson and Gasser were really money in the second half, and the bullpen was downright historic in the playoffs

Posted
8 hours ago, igor67 said:

May did enough along with Romero that the deal was a net loss, but not a cosmically bad one. Winning the WS puts it into the category of things to be forgotten. Not all trades are going to work out the way you want when it comes to performance. But definitely both the need for the trade and the amount of the FA signing reinforce the need for trying have as much pitching depth in the offseason as possible since it is way too expensive at the deadline

What JoJo did especially in the playoffs made up for all the bad May did.  I consider the trade a success because we won a WS and JoJo was a significant part of that.  Don’t really care what they gave up since we won the WS.

  • Like 7
  • Disagree 1
Posted
12 hours ago, adambr2 said:

May and Romero for Frias and Ragsdale definitely felt like acting on it. 

Have we resigned Romero yet   That’s really what I would prefer 

  • Like 1
Posted
On 11/17/2026 at 12:16 PM, patrickgpe said:

Also I can't wait to see what Freddy Peralta's deal looks like if May got this. 

I had this thought, but also wondered:

What would Peralta have gotten had he stayed with the Mets and sucked the entire year? I wonder if he still banks a $100mil+ in that situation.

It is funny how May despite little success is considered young with potential and a single bad year after 30 would make teams question if Peralta is old and washed up.

This is why I chuckled in the ‘should we go get a starter thread’. Our question marks would be worth $20mil+ on the open market and probably get multi year deals like May. We ain’t improving on what we got. 

 

Posted
1 hour ago, MrTPlush said:

I had this thought, but also wondered:

What would Peralta have gotten had he stayed with the Mets and sucked the entire year? I wonder if he still banks a $100mil+ in that situation.

It is funny how May despite little success is considered young with potential and a single bad year after 30 would make teams question if Peralta is old and washed up.

This is why I chuckled in the ‘should we go get a starter thread’. Our question marks would be worth $20mil+ on the open market and probably get multi year deals like May. We ain’t improving on what we got. 

 

Maybe I'm wrong but I'm not sure Peralta actually did much for his FA value in Tampa. The results were certainly better but as we can see with Dustin May teams are looking much deeper than results when it comes to pitchers. The gap in the underlying numbers for Peralta between New York and Tampa was pretty small. Seems like the only thing he really did better in Tampa was suppress HR which could just be small sample noise considering Freddy has never really been a big HR suppression guy.

Freddy in NY vs Tampa

ERA- 121 vs 78

FIP- 106 vs 94

xFIP- 101 vs 112

xERA - 3.86 vs 3.74

SIERA - 4.30 vs 4.43

K-BB% - 12.7% vs 12.8%

Stuff+ - 96 vs 99

Posted

Sure would be curious if and what the Brewers offered Freddy before trading him. Say it was something like a 4/80, he's right to think he'd get more than that but with how the last year went he probably would be happier to have just stayed here and put that in the bank.

There's also a very good chance we didn't even bother offering/negotiating since they knew it was impossible so didn't want to insult him with a low offer

Posted
2 hours ago, MrTPlush said:

I had this thought, but also wondered:

What would Peralta have gotten had he stayed with the Mets and sucked the entire year? I wonder if he still banks a $100mil+ in that situation.

It is funny how May despite little success is considered young with potential and a single bad year after 30 would make teams question if Peralta is old and washed up.

 

 

I still think Peralta gets 100 Million if he stayed and was bad. I honestly don't know how much extra his Rays playoff run got him. He had the track record with Milwaukee and teams are so desperate for pitching they would pay him for the chance to return him to Brewers form. 

  • Like 1
Posted
17 hours ago, thammondwis said:

What JoJo did especially in the playoffs made up for all the bad May did.  I consider the trade a success because we won a WS and JoJo was a significant part of that.  Don’t really care what they gave up since we won the WS.

You don't think they were winning that WS without JoJo or May? 

They gave up an 18-year-old with massive power and a top 100 prospect and Ragsdale... who I was actually fine with. But just winning doesn't mean every trade was worth it. Made for Skubal... we'd almost certainly have won it. I wouldn't have defended it. 

But, I am not as annoyed by the trade obviously because... winning it IS objectively cool, but I don't agree with the logic. 

.

Posted
7 hours ago, willie key said:

Have we resigned Romero yet   That’s really what I would prefer 

I don't think they'll even try and re-sign Romero. 3/30 is likely what it'll cost and I don't think we'll pay it. I also think Senzatela is a better choice as I believe he'll sign for much cheaper. 

Upper 90s fastball, he's got a starters mix and he's a heavy GB pitcher. 

I'd also take May back if it would have been reasonable. He's got the same things going for him. Big arm, velo, he USED to be a big GB pitcher. At 1/8M he was worth it. AT 20M+ which... he was always going to get, obviously not. Clay Holmes would be far more interesting at this point, but I suspect hell also cost 15M AAV and get 3 years. 

So... we'll just have to keep getting by with our sad, little pitching development! 

.

Posted

He is a 3-time WS champion, May is a simply a winner!

Sometimes I wonder if we just need to have something to complain about?  May didn't work out, but he helped (a little).  JoJo was excellent.  The price to go get Skubal was very high (Henderson+?).  

If May had come in and "simply" retained a mid-4 ERA, I think the trade is a clear success.  As it is, Frias and Ragsdale have to make positive impact at the majors before we "lose" the trade.  That isn't a lock.  

Frankly JoJo's impact in the playoffs alone (and the WS victory) were enough for me to be fine with the cost of Frias and Ragsdale. They had a lot of hurdles in their way in the Brewer org to provide MLB impact. 

 

  • Like 1

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted
On 11/18/2026 at 4:03 PM, BrewerFan said:

You don't think they were winning that WS without JoJo or May? 

They gave up an 18-year-old with massive power and a top 100 prospect and Ragsdale... who I was actually fine with. But just winning doesn't mean every trade was worth it. Made for Skubal... we'd almost certainly have won it. I wouldn't have defended it. 

But, I am not as annoyed by the trade obviously because... winning it IS objectively cool, but I don't agree with the logic. 

Could they have won without that trade…sure.

I’ve been waiting a loooooooooooooooooong time for this and wanted us to have the best odds of doing it.  Which is why I was willing to give up our best prospects for it.  I honestly didn’t think we had good odds to win it all after the Skubal deal.

I was wrong and glad I was.  No that we do have a WS championship, I’m more on a pragmatic approach on trying to repeat.

 

Posted
1 hour ago, CheezWizHed said:

As it is, Frias and Ragsdale have to make positive impact at the majors before we "lose" the trade.  That isn't a lock.  

Disagree on this. The team should have gotten a better player(s), likely with at least a little control, for those prospects.

  • Like 2
Posted
37 minutes ago, wallus said:

Disagree on this. The team should have gotten a better player(s), likely with at least a little control, for those prospects.

There are some wildly disagreeing opinions on the value of Frias and Ragsdale.  You obviously rank them much higher than I. Despite what you or I think of them... the proof tends to come with the results.  

So either a better trade wasn't available for these two players (there are often only limited options) or GMs didn't value them as highly as you think.

The Brewers do have a pretty good history of not losing great players in these trades.  They've lost one or two that I'm sure they'd prefer to have back (Reese, Fry)... but also robbed people blind (Yelich, Contreras) on trades, too.  Many of them have been a wash. 

  • Like 1

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted

I don't think the trade was bad on its face. It made sense, I see why they did it, May has pretty top of the line stuff. I don't think it was a move for the sake of a move. I think they really thought it was a win-now move with minimal prospect loss. 

My take is not really organizational criticism. May was just bad. I guess my only critique would be that he hasn't produced good results for some time, but that's about the guy you can expect to get for what we traded away.

I think May gets by on sheer talent, but he seems to lack a bit of mental fortitude. Every time a guy got on base, you could tell just by looking at him he was anxious. I don't think the lab could have done much with that. I just got the sense he had a lack of mettle. He didn't fit in with the underlying mentality/make up of the team. 

Posted

May will be 30 next year and injury history. 

Career Injury Timeline.

YearInjury / IssueImpact / Notes

2019Neck injuryDay-to-day in September; missed 4 games

2021Right arm / elbow (Tommy John surgery)Placed on IL in May; missed remainder of 2021 and early 2022

2022Lower back tightnessPlaced on 15-day IL in September; missed final 11 regular-season games

2023Forearm / flexor tendon & elbow surgeryExited May start; underwent surgery in July 2023

2024Elbow recovery & torn esophagusMissed entire 2024 season after emergency esophagus surgery

2025Right elbow ulnar neuritisPlaced on 15-day IL in September; missed final 20 regular-season games

2026Back tightness, right ankle contusion, right scapula contusionShort absences/day-to-day stints (2–3 games missed each); finished with 145⅔ innings.

Posted
13 minutes ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

I don't think it was a move for the sake of a move.

While i agree they didnt just do it to make a move, they had established a clear expectation across the org and in the media that they were going to be buyers this year. Arnold was saying it interviews, Murphy was referencing it some of his press conferences. For whatever reason, they felt the need to put it out there and make it clear this was going to happen well before the May trade. That would be a tough thing to walk back from with the fans and the team.

You could also hear it in the sound bites and body language that they really felt they had the winning offer for Skubal. May seemed a very distant plan B and you have to trust your scouting that has gotten you this far already. 

Posted
28 minutes ago, CheezWizHed said:

There are some wildly disagreeing opinions on the value of Frias and Ragsdale.  You obviously rank them much higher than I. Despite what you or I think of them... the proof tends to come with the results.  

So either a better trade wasn't available for these two players (there are often only limited options) or GMs didn't value them as highly as you think.

The Brewers do have a pretty good history of not losing great players in these trades.  They've lost one or two that I'm sure they'd prefer to have back (Reese, Fry)... but also robbed people blind (Yelich, Contreras) on trades, too.  Many of them have been a wash. 

You could say that about any trade that involves prospects. Opportunity cost is real on here and I think Arnold made a bad trade. They likely put a lot of focus into Skubal and thought they had a deal done for him. Then they felt they needed to make a quick move afterwards and missed.

I don't think he's a bad GM, in fact I think he's a great GM but even those guys make mistakes.

  • Like 2
Posted
56 minutes ago, cragi said:

While i agree they didnt just do it to make a move, they had established a clear expectation across the org and in the media that they were going to be buyers this year. Arnold was saying it interviews, Murphy was referencing it some of his press conferences. For whatever reason, they felt the need to put it out there and make it clear this was going to happen well before the May trade. That would be a tough thing to walk back from with the fans and the team.

You could also hear it in the sound bites and body language that they really felt they had the winning offer for Skubal. May seemed a very distant plan B and you have to trust your scouting that has gotten you this far already. 

If what we have been hearing about Skubal is true, they did everything possible to land him. But who cares - he'd be gone anyway and it was even better to beat him.

  • Like 2
Posted

Yea besides the cost acquiring issues. Besides just being better to beat him, it really was better for the story that it was done this way and that the 'team' itself got all the credit. If they got him, it turns out they likely win as well but the whole narrative would be on how HE put them over the top and they couldn't do it without him, etc.  Very glad it worked out the way it did

  • Like 2
Posted
52 minutes ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

If what we have been hearing about Skubal is true, they did everything possible to land him. But who cares - he'd be gone anyway and it was even better to beat him.

.. and keep Henderson, Pena and Adamczewski

  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, tmwiese55 said:

Yea besides the cost acquiring issues. Besides just being better to beat him, it really was better for the story that it was done this way and that the 'team' itself got all the credit. If they got him, it turns out they likely win as well but the whole narrative would be on how HE put them over the top and they couldn't do it without him, etc.  Very glad it worked out the way it did

Damn this is such a good point. I wanted Skubal, but over the years I’ve generally been accepting of the “bites of the apple” approach. 
 

You’re spot on with what the narrative would have been. And we’d be right back in the same place where everyone from the national media and social media would be clamoring for us to “make the all in move” again next deadline. 
 

We may not win the World Series again soon, but at least I can more easily ignore the discourse

  • Like 2

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...