Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted

Are we in line for a comp pick after the 1st if Misi is top 3 in the Cy Young? Pretty sure thay we are in line for a comp A pick. Maybe Bauers could catch fire the last month and a half and decline a qualifying offer (unlikely).

I will throw up the 1st interesting prospect (who likely will go to high for us)

Striker Pence- 6'6" power right who throws 100 routinely. As a HS prospect, he declassified to 2027 from 28 so he is a tad younger. He also is a decent hitter and is from Corona, CA (not same HS as Ebel's). In all likelihood he is a top 20 pick and we dont take HS pitchers so he probably isn't a Brewer in a year.

Recommended Posts

Posted

No you need on the roster to start your rookie year or to be called up within the first two weeks of the season to be eligible for PPI so Misiorowski winning Cy Young would not net us a PPI pick.

  • Like 1
Posted

No compensation for not signing Knaak, correct (only for 1st/2nd rounders?)

And they will be in line for another competitive balance pick - is it A or B this upcoming year, or is that a lottery thing?

And Bauers is the only FA that could recieve a QO?

Posted
9 hours ago, jay87shot said:

Are we in line for a comp pick after the 1st if Misi is top 3 in the Cy Young? Pretty sure thay we are in line for a comp A pick. Maybe Bauers could catch fire the last month and a half and decline a qualifying offer (unlikely).

I will throw up the 1st interesting prospect (who likely will go to high for us)

Striker Pence- 6'6" power right who throws 100 routinely. As a HS prospect, he declassified to 2027 from 28 so he is a tad younger. He also is a decent hitter and is from Corona, CA (not same HS as Ebel's). In all likelihood he is a top 20 pick and we dont take HS pitchers so he probably isn't a Brewer in a year.

Also plays on the brewers area code team with trey ebel  and Julian Garcia 

Brewer Fanatic Contributor
Posted
9 hours ago, jay87shot said:

Pretty sure thay we are in line for a comp A pick.

Assuming all remains the same post-CBA discussions (or even if there's a change that it might not affect the first draft after), the Brewers will be in line for a Competitive Balance A pick, yes.

1 hour ago, biedergb said:

No compensation for not signing Knaak, correct (only for 1st/2nd rounders?)

This is correct, no compensation for not signing Knaak.

  • Like 1
Verified Member
Posted

I know the Brewers have their methods and it’s hard to argue with the results, but I really hope they grab a high upside TOR type starting pitcher in the 1st round next year. The system needs so more high end pitching prospects. 

  • Like 2
Verified Member
Posted
1 hour ago, paul253 said:

I know the Brewers have their methods and it’s hard to argue with the results, but I really hope they grab a high upside TOR type starting pitcher in the 1st round next year. The system needs so more high end pitching prospects. 

Those types are not normally available where the Brewers have been picking.  Best case scenario is you find someone like Miz worst case scenario you find someone who doesn’t even make it to the majors.  You have to get extremely lucky or find a diamond in the rough.

  • Like 1
Posted
23 hours ago, Joseph Zarr said:

Well, shoot:

 

That pretty clearly points to an international draft. Hopefully this doesn't hurt our international scouting advantage to much.

Community Moderator
Posted
On 8/22/2026 at 7:35 PM, jay87shot said:

That pretty clearly points to an international draft. Hopefully this doesn't hurt our international scouting advantage to much.

The question will be if the teams that do poorly in the international realm is because they identify the wrong talent or don't want to spend the money?  If it is the former, the top end talent is going to be available late when the Brewers pick anyway.  But the Brewers seem to be able to find the diamonds lower in the "rankings" anyway.  

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted
On 8/19/2026 at 12:33 PM, nate82 said:

Those types are not normally available where the Brewers have been picking.  Best case scenario is you find someone like Miz worst case scenario you find someone who doesn’t even make it to the majors.  You have to get extremely lucky or find a diamond in the rough.

There are plenty of high upside arms when the Brewers are drafting in the first rd, the 2nd rd... 

There were like 8 pitchers taken in the 10 picks after our 1st rd pick this year. 
You had guys like Gage Wood, Marcus Phillips, AJ Russell, Riley Quick, Kruz Schoolcraft... and plenty more.

Also, if the worst case is a guy doesn't make it to the majors... we're going to have a lot of worst case outcomes every year irrespective of position. 

 

.

  • 2 months later...
Posted

Let’s just say the draft rules go unchanged in the CBA and we get at least one more year with high school players in the draft.

We won the World Series. We have a Comp A first rounder. We have a potential comp pick for Bauers with a qualifying offer. Would this be our largest bonus pool to date?

I can’t wait to see what these guys do.

Verified Member
Posted
On 10/31/2026 at 2:46 PM, snoogans8056 said:

Let’s just say the draft rules go unchanged in the CBA and we get at least one more year with high school players in the draft.

We won the World Series. We have a Comp A first rounder. We have a potential comp pick for Bauers with a qualifying offer. Would this be our largest bonus pool to date?

I can’t wait to see what these guys do.

If Bauers rejects the QO and signs for N of $50M — then I believe we will have our largest bonus-pool allotment ever — likely near $14M.

Last year we had ~$8M after trading away our Comp B pick. This upcoming draft we get the compensation pick A & competitive balance pick A, which should add ~$6M to last years total.

Verified Member
Posted
On 8/19/2026 at 11:07 AM, paul253 said:

I know the Brewers have their methods and it’s hard to argue with the results, but I really hope they grab a high upside TOR type starting pitcher in the 1st round next year. The system needs so more high end pitching prospects. 

With the control the team has over their BL position players along with the incredible depth of positionals throughout the system, including perhaps their deepest IFA draft (2026) of positionals, ever, I’m hoping the team can focus on adding arm talent with the ‘27 draft.

The pitching developed post Miz-Gasser-Harrison-Henderson et all will determine if this is a 5 or a 7-8 year dynasty ahead.

  • Like 4
Posted
18 hours ago, rccola42 said:

Add another Comp A pick to the mix with the Bauers signing.

And with a likely Brewers record amount of bonus pool money to go with it.

This upcoming draft along with their last IFA class has a high-likelihood of extending the team’s WS contention well beyond the next 5-7 year period of time. 

The MKE Amateur Draft-Department, imo, has become more and more elite with each passing draft-class. 

Last years class is looking early-on, like a simply incredible class, especially considering they only had $8M in pool money to spend. Great reports at instructs from numerous pitchers and hitters has me convinced this is now the best ADD in all of baseball, with it firing on all-cylinders to a max degree.

What’s happening with this organization is almost beyond belief. This next 7-10 years will shock the baseball world — The most dominant era of baseball played by any team since the Yankees of the 90’s and in baseball’s smallest-market — beyond remarkable.

  • Like 1
  • Love 1
Posted

I have a fairly generic question re: the MLB draft and compensation for picks, etc. Hoping to have someone with a better handle on the operation answer.

Bonus pool vs number of picks. The bonus pool is the assigned value of the picks you have in the first 10 rds and that is the money you have to spend on the totality of your picks (overage not included), is that correct?

So hypothetically, if the Brewers were to trade and acquire another Comp B pick from someone ... we add the value of that pick to our bonus pool allotment?

So is it reasonable to say that the excitement with a team like Milwaukee (who seems to utilize their draft pool money well) in adding the extra pick from Bauers is two fold? One for the extra player to be added (obviously) but also in the extra money we are adding to our pool that we can now 'manipulate' across all picks? Is that a fair analysis?

Posted
51 minutes ago, liveforoctober said:

I have a fairly generic question re: the MLB draft and compensation for picks, etc. Hoping to have someone with a better handle on the operation answer.

Bonus pool vs number of picks. The bonus pool is the assigned value of the picks you have in the first 10 rds and that is the money you have to spend on the totality of your picks (overage not included), is that correct?

So hypothetically, if the Brewers were to trade and acquire another Comp B pick from someone ... we add the value of that pick to our bonus pool allotment?

So is it reasonable to say that the excitement with a team like Milwaukee (who seems to utilize their draft pool money well) in adding the extra pick from Bauers is two fold? One for the extra player to be added (obviously) but also in the extra money we are adding to our pool that we can now 'manipulate' across all picks? Is that a fair analysis?

No, you lose the money from that pick when it’s no longer yours. Whoever we’d trade that pick to would get the bonus money.

That being said, we’ve traded our last two comp picks to Boston for Priester and Harrison.

Posted
8 minutes ago, snoogans8056 said:

No, you lose the money from that pick when it’s no longer yours. Whoever we’d trade that pick to would get the bonus money.

That being said, we’ve traded our last two comp picks to Boston for Priester and Harrison.

I probably said that wrong - I meant if we acquire a comp pick we get the money that comes with it added..

Posted
14 hours ago, SF70 said:

And with a likely Brewers record amount of bonus pool money to go with it.

This upcoming draft along with their last IFA class has a high-likelihood of extending the team’s WS contention well beyond the next 5-7 year period of time. 

The MKE Amateur Draft-Department, imo, has become more and more elite with each passing draft-class. 

Last years class is looking early-on, like a simply incredible class, especially considering they only had $8M in pool money to spend. Great reports at instructs from numerous pitchers and hitters has me convinced this is now the best ADD in all of baseball, with it firing on all-cylinders to a max degree.

What’s happening with this organization is almost beyond belief. This next 7-10 years will shock the baseball world — The most dominant era of baseball played by any team since the Yankees of the 90’s and in baseball’s smallest-market — beyond remarkable.

That is encouraging to hear the positive news about last years draft class.  I haven’t heard any news, what have you heard about how players are progressing?

Posted
7 hours ago, Cowbell said:

That is encouraging to hear the positive news about last years draft class.  I haven’t heard any news, what have you heard about how players are progressing?

BA had Keaton Maiorana up to 97 at instructs. Ben Badler made mention of Julian Garcia also impressive at instructs. Heard good things on both Hart and Ruby post-draft. Strong underlying numbers from Trey Ebel with Wilson, big exit velo from Strosnyder at Wisconsin.

Just a lot of upside with this class, especially considering they had such a small bonus pool.

  • Like 2
Posted
8 hours ago, SF70 said:

BA had Keaton Maiorana up to 97 at instructs. Ben Badler made mention of Julian Garcia also impressive at instructs. Heard good things on both Hart and Ruby post-draft. Strong underlying numbers from Trey Ebel with Wilson, big exit velo from Strosnyder at Wisconsin.

Just a lot of upside with this class, especially considering they had such a small bonus pool.

Also have Flores coming back from TJ who was a 4th round high schooler from the year before. Also Cairone the second rounder should be recovered a bit more from the car accident.

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...