Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Recommended Posts

Posted

A good reminder of why the Brewers don’t sign free agents, especially early in the off season. 
 

I thought Dustin May would work out for us, at least better than he did. My inkling is that whatever adjustments we tried to make with him just weren’t sticking and he ended up performing worse for us than he did with the Cardinals. 
 

I hope he pitches well for the White Sox. 

  • Like 7
Posted

Thank you for your service and time helping us win the world series!  Enjoy your bags!  

  • Like 2

Posted: July 10, 2014, 12:30 AM

PrinceFielderx1 Said:

If the Brewers don't win the division I should be banned. However, they will.

 

Last visited: September 03, 2014, 7:10 PM

Posted
17 minutes ago, KCBrewerfan34 said:

How does May keep pulling off these 8 figure deals, All other FA pitchers just gave May a high 5 and thank you. 

It's the prize behind the puzzle. If you are built like a big leaguer and have the physical tools of a big leaguer ... teams can't help themselves believing they can be the one to unlock you.

I'll never forget sitting and talking with a White Sox scout during a TRats game in the early 2000s. We had a guy on the team named Mike Wilson, outfielder. Built like a middle linebacker. He struggled early season and was striking out a ton, not getting on base. But when he connected with one he hit it over Hwy 41. We had another outfielder on that team named Sebastien Boucher. Canadian kid, centerfielder. I thought he was awesome. Dylan O'Rae type of hitter, not a ton of power but all fields and was always on base. He matched Asdrubal Cabrera's production day in and day out.

This guy wasn't giving Boucher a 2nd look because "not a MLB body, he won't make it". But he was salivating over Wilson. "He will be able to withstand the grind" "Major league fastballs won't intimidate him". He could have cared less about the at bat to at bat results ... he was looking for a body that could be put into the machine.

May is 6'6 and has a tool bag that should dazzle. Whoever unlocks it has a TOR guy. Can anyone unlock it is the question. Most want to try.

  • Like 4
Posted
6 minutes ago, liveforoctober said:

It's the prize behind the puzzle. If you are built like a big leaguer and have the physical tools of a big leaguer ... teams can't help themselves believing they can be the one to unlock you.

I'll never forget sitting and talking with a White Sox scout during a TRats game in the early 2000s. We had a guy on the team named Mike Wilson, outfielder. Built like a middle linebacker. He struggled early season and was striking out a ton, not getting on base. But when he connected with one he hit it over Hwy 41. We had another outfielder on that team named Sebastien Boucher. Canadian kid, centerfielder. I thought he was awesome. Dylan O'Rae type of hitter, not a ton of power but all fields and was always on base. He matched Asdrubal Cabrera's production day in and day out.

This guy wasn't giving Boucher a 2nd look because "not a MLB body, he won't make it". But he was salivating over Wilson. "He will be able to withstand the grind" "Major league fastballs won't intimidate him". He could have cared less about the at bat to at bat results ... he was looking for a body that could be put into the machine.

May is 6'6 and has a tool bag that should dazzle. Whoever unlocks it has a TOR guy. Can anyone unlock it is the question. Most want to try.

We all remember MLB legend Sebastien Boucher!

  • WHOA SOLVDD 1
Posted
5 minutes ago, liveforoctober said:

May is 6'6 and has a tool bag that should dazzle. Whoever unlocks it has a TOR guy. Can anyone unlock it is the question. Most want to try.

If the Brewers couldn't do it, it may not be possible.

Good luck to May, though. He seemed like a fun dude, and had some nice moments as a Brewer. He performed the role he was expected to, more or less. 

  • Like 3
Posted

May just got more money than Bauers... Let that one sink in. 😬

Yes, he is 2 years younger and Bauers is a risk for regressing... but May doesn't have anything but "potential" (i.e. a big arm) and no real history of results to back him up. 

The cost of starting pitching... woof. 

  • Like 4

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted
4 minutes ago, CheezWizHed said:

May just got more money than Bauers... Let that one sink in

Well AAV, yes. but 52.5 is less than 58, so strictly speaking he did not get more money than Baurs. :)
You ended with the key point though - starting pitchers make a lot of money.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Team Canada said:

Well AAV, yes. but 52.5 is less than 58, so strictly speaking he did not get more money than Baurs. :)
You ended with the key point though - starting pitchers make a lot of money.

Well, then you have to wait until year 4 to see if May is signed for $6M or more. 😛

Yes, I was focused on AAV. 

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted

I understand that there is an estabilished market for starting pitchers and May was slotted in where he was. He was OK for the cardinals and had one decent apperance after being traded here. Still his ERA was 4.70 and had a WAR of 2.8. If the Brewers gave hin this, this thread would be 20 pages long by now and full of unhappy Brewer fans. 

Just be thankful that the Brewers seem to always have a bunch of young, talented controllable starters that they trade for or draft, eliminating the need to do this kind of stuff. 

Also I can't wait to see what Freddy Peralta's deal looks like if May got this. 

  • Like 2
Community Moderator
Posted

I feel bad for White Sox fans. Hopefully it ages better than the Luis Castillo trade. 

I don't understand why you would go through a rebuild and then start throwing money down the toilet as soon as you get good. At least he'll fill a slot in their rotation, which can't be said for the $23 million they are paying Castillo for '27, but there has to be a better way to spend that money. 

Posted
1 hour ago, patrickgpe said:

He was OK for the cardinals and had one decent apperance after being traded here.

Three good starts for the Brewers ... against the Pirates on Aug. 6, Padres on Aug. 12 and Reds on Sept. 11. 

Posted
2 hours ago, Ron Robinsons Beard said:

If the Brewers couldn't do it, it may not be possible.

Good luck to May, though. He seemed like a fun dude, and had some nice moments as a Brewer. He performed the role he was expected to, more or less. 

Not sure the Brewers had much time to "fix" him. Hard to do that with a trade deadline acquisition in a pennant race. They already know JoJo was going to miss a month, they needed May to hit the ground running. 

  • Like 1

"Go ahead. Try to disagree with me. I dare you." Jeffrey Leonard.

Posted
2 hours ago, Ron Robinsons Beard said:

If the Brewers couldn't do it, it may not be possible.

Good luck to May, though. He seemed like a fun dude, and had some nice moments as a Brewer. He performed the role he was expected to, more or less. 

Less. Definitely less.

The bullpen was the biggest part of our postseason success and Romero was a big part of that. So there will at least always be that. 

Posted
1 minute ago, adambr2 said:

Less. Definitely less.

The bullpen was the biggest part of our postseason success and Romero was a big part of that. So there will at least always be that. 

His main role was to keep innings off the team's top young arms. It could be argued that a guy like Coleman Crow may have been able to do the same thing, though.

  • Like 2
Posted
1 minute ago, Ron Robinsons Beard said:

His main role was to keep innings off the team's top young arms. It could be argued that a guy like Coleman Crow may have been able to do the same thing, though.

If the goal was to do what May did, they could have done with any shuttle bus from Nashville. You don't give up what the Brewers did unless you think May is going to meaningfully contribute, which he did not.

  • Like 5
Posted
1 minute ago, Ron Robinsons Beard said:

His main role was to keep innings off the team's top young arms. It could be argued that a guy like Coleman Crow may have been able to do the same thing, though.

Right, he only ended up pitching 36 2/3rds innings for us, which I’d argue could have easily been eaten up by others.

I understand that people are going to argue that any move we made is justified by the fact that we won the World Series, I don’t really agree with that and it’s more of a correlation/causation argument. I think we win the World Series if we completely stand pat at the deadline.

I definitely won’t argue that Romero wasn’t very helpful and effective in October, though. 

  • Like 2
Posted
4 minutes ago, Ron Robinsons Beard said:

His main role was to keep innings off the team's top young arms. It could be argued that a guy like Coleman Crow may have been able to do the same thing, though.

I know Crow isn't a "top young arm" but he was in the same boat as the other young pitchers in creeping up on usage limits. He only threw 50 innings in 2025 and had only thrown 74 innings since the start of 2023 because of TJ surgery. He ended up throwing 124 innings this season.

Posted
Just now, adambr2 said:

Right, he only ended up pitching 36 2/3rds innings for us, which I’d argue could have easily been eaten up by others.

I understand that people are going to argue that any move we made is justified by the fact that we won the World Series, I don’t really agree with that and it’s more of a correlation/causation argument. I think we win the World Series if we completely stand pat at the deadline.

I definitely won’t argue that Romero wasn’t very helpful and effective in October, though. 

I'm sure the Brewers had an established ceiling and floor when it came to their expectations for May, and I'd bet that they feel his results were closer to the floor (hence the option not being picked up). But he wasn't an abject disaster, either. He had enough good moments to serve a purpose.

I agree on Romero, and would love to see him re-signed.  

Posted

I think its a good deal for a team like the white sox. They were surprisingly good and SP isn't cheap but in their spot getting a mid level guy like him while only having to commit three years is good. Barring another TJ no matter what happens it can't get you in too much trouble. And if/when some of their good younger hitters need extensions or to be paid real money he'll be off the books.  Seems like a good middle ground for them to help continue to try and win a very bad division while also not mortgaging any future.  

Good spot for him imo too going to such a crap division with weak offenses.  A team like SD with a huge park could've made sense too after they miss on Skubal, but he probably doesn't want to wait on that, plus in spite of playing for LAD he does not come across as a SoCal guy at all from interviews I've seen with him on MLB network.. 

Well I know the results aren't there, everyone can see the 100 and massive breaking slider, the stuff is there and tantalizing to GMs. If you get him to be a level more consistent you have a steal, if he maintains just being OK its a generally fair deal in today's market. Its kind of a can't majorly lose, barring big injury.  I could also see that if in these 3 years he only maintains this OK level that he could probably transition to closer type and do pretty well at it. Just focus on FB and keeping that massive slider closer to the zone.

ETA: and to some of the post that just came in on their expectations when they got him etc. I think something to note is at the time of the trade the division was still very much up for grabs so their was more urgency from them to hope for the upside of May. If they'd have known how well things would go from there for the rest of the team, I think they'd have been perfectly fine with AAAA types going up and down to eat some innings. At the time though, trying to squeak out 2-3 extra wins seemed important which might've led to overpaying.  Plus probably some "skubal fell through, we have to do something" attitude. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...