2021-07-11: Reds (Castillo) at Brewers (Woodruff) [Brewers lose, 3-1 -- Crew hits a speed bump heading into the All Star Break]

[Eye Black]

I hate baseball’s use of replay. It’s just so silly.

 

In theory replay should be an incredible asset. In actual practice it’s often applied different from its intent.

[pacopete4]

You shouldn’t be able to block the bag with your foot. That’s the first part about all of this.

[82brewcrew82]

Where is the definitive view?

[trwi7]

You guys can hate the fact that that type of review is allowed but he was pretty clearly off the base when the tag was still applied.

[Cool Hand Lucroy]

There needs to be a safe zone after initial comtact with the base.

[Simba2020]

I also thought he was out.

[82brewcrew82]

You guys can hate the fact that that type of review is allowed but he was pretty clearly off the base when the tag was still applied.

Post the view that shows him clearly off the bag?

[DHonks]

There’s no way that was conclusive. Why does NY hate the Brewers so much? We lose inconclusive plays that were initially called our way. We lose obvious plays that we’re called wrong but then not overturned like they should have been.

[gebc1997]

He was not clearly off the bag!!!!

[trwi7]

Where is the definitive view?

 

The behind the base view was pretty definitive.

[brewers888]

There was no definitive proof he was out. Call should have stood regardless of what call was initially made. Edited July 11, 2021 by brewers888

[ReverendBrewmeister]

Need to go in cleats thigh high to put an end to the base blocking.

 

Also MLB headquarters can collapse and the game would benefit from it.

[adambr2]

There has to be a different angle that we can't see that clearly shows the foot leave the bag. They can't be reversing based on that look.

[titletownking]

trying to be positive. really really trying. but somebody needs to get rid of manfred. all i'm saying.

[brewcrewdue80]

Looks like Adames can spend his AS break working on sliding in to 2b. Yeesh. I mean he should know better he plays SS!

[JET15]

The SB got us our run, but this time the attempt may have cost us the game

[gebc1997]

Don’t sit there and blatantly say he was clearly off the bag. Nobody can say that. That’s ridiculous to even remotely state that

[brewers888]

trying to be positive. really really trying. but somebody needs to get rid of manfred. all i'm saying.

 

Absolutely awful commissioner.

[adambr2]

There needs to be a safe zone after initial comtact with the base.

 

Not sure what you're saying here. Like, you shouldn't have to actually stay on the base?

[82brewcrew82]

Where is the definitive view?

 

The behind the base view was pretty definitive.

No

[Sir Illo]

You guys can hate the fact that that type of review is allowed but he was pretty clearly off the base when the tag was still applied.

 

True. His foot left the bag and he was tagged. Isn’t the runner entitled to some access to the bag however? If guy’s foot isn’t dead center, thus forcing Adames’ foot off the bag, he’s pretty clearly safe.

[DHonks]

You guys can hate the fact that that type of review is allowed but he was pretty clearly off the base when the tag was still applied.

 

Except he wasn’t.

He was called safe. While all angles show his foot move/shift, there’s no angle that shows a gap between the foot and the bag. You can’t see that his spikes weren’t on the bag. Sorry, you’re just flat wrong

[Ron Robinsons Beard]

Where is the definitive view?

 

The behind the base view was pretty definitive.

 

On what earth was that definitive?

[trwi7]

You guys, that behind the base view where it looks like his foot is off (because it is and you can see him slam his foot back into the base while the tag is still being applied) is about as definitive as you can get.

[gebc1997]

Ridiculously wrong, wrong to the point of being wrong to be anti Brewers