Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Verified Member
Posted

Rank the offseason priorities for the team. Here's mine...

1. #2/#3 starter. I think the team was hoping Woodruff would be that guy last season but he got injured. That made them overpay for May. Ultimately it worked out but I am hoping the team will focus on spending any payroll money they have before the season starts. With the wildcard and so many teams not selling, the trade deadline is a mess as a buyer. 

2. Relief pitching. A number of guys will likely not be back from the WS team (sounds good to say that phrase). Senzatella, Romero, and I guess Woodruff counts on that. It would be nice to get another guy for the pen.

3. Catcher. I would be fine with an El Gary reunion or maybe pickup Tyler Stephenson. Stephenson screams Brewer as a guy that struggles with framing, can hit a little bit and actually has better away stats.

What say you?

  • Like 1

Recommended Posts

Posted

1) Resolve first base. Maybe it’s as simple at Bauers accepting the QO. If he declines, the situation gets more interesting. I’m personally fine with transitioning to Vaughn and a lefty complement, but Bauers was our best hitter last year. Losing him would be a big loss. I don’t think I’d advocate for a multi year deal with Bauers though. 
 

2) I think we need to add a starter or 2. I kinda think there’s a non-zero chance Sproat gets Tobias Myers’d. If he does, we definitely need 2 starters. I wouldn’t go so far as to say we need to add a guy who can start playoff games though. Maybe it’s a veteran starter in the Brett Anderson or Jose Quintana mold. Or maybe it’s an undervalued minor leaguer like Drohan. Or maybe a former prospect whose star has faded like Harrison. I know we have 9 SP on the 40 man already, but who knows what you’ll get from Priester and Gordon/Crow are more depth guys to me. And if they want to try Ashby, hall, or Patrick back in the rotation then it’s shifting the hole to the pen. This might involve trading guys off the big league roster like Ortiz or Mitchell, 
3) extend Made. It won’t be cheap, but I’d just love to have him locked it. I know he will basically be on the same time frame for team control as Chourio, but it would be nice to have him stretched out a little longer (assuming no change in the 6 full years of service time to reach free agency)

 

I’ll just mention it, I’m not interested in extending Contreras, but I also don’t want them to trade him. Let 2027 play out and be ok with losing him in free agency  

 

Verified Member
Posted

1 extending Contreras. Not the $100M+ deals being thrown around, but see if something is available below that

2 solving the future at catcher. either a blockbuster prospect deal or a high draft pick.

3 extending prospects and young pitchers. Made, Burke, Payne, Adamczewski. Harrison, Gasser, Priester, etc. Find younger guys who bring value and extend them before they hit the market.

Posted

1. Sign Sir William   3 years/$75 mill with an additional 4th year with a team option at $25 mill with a team with a $5 mill buyout.  Either 3/75+5 or 4/100.

2. Extend Made. Switch hitting middle infielder that can run and built like a linebacker don't come around very often.

3. Listen to offers on our other talents.  Andrew Vaughn (assuming Jake Bauer stays), Garrett Mitchell, Sal Frelick, Joey Ortiz can all go, but only for an great deal. 

I think our pitching will work itself out with Priester and Zerpa coming back and Sproats and Drohan improving with age.  We also know that Harrison can pitch well, we just need to get him over the line. Mis,Henderson and Gasser are a good 1,2,3 Priester at 4 and Harrison at 5.  Maybe Woody on a cheap contract and limit his pitch count until September.

Verified Member
Posted
1 hour ago, cragi said:

1 extending Contreras. Not the $100M+ deals being thrown around, but see if something is available below that

2 solving the future at catcher. either a blockbuster prospect deal or a high draft pick.

3 extending prospects and young pitchers. Made, Burke, Payne, Adamczewski. Harrison, Gasser, Priester, etc. Find younger guys who bring value and extend them before they hit the market.

1.  There will be nothing available below that 100 million mark you mention.  To offer him any less will be disrespectful.  My guess is he will want a 5-6 year deal, probably around 125-150 million.

2. Extending Contreras would solve our future at catcher, at least our near future, say 3 years until he has to DH the last two years of his extension. 

3. You simply can't extend all those guys, and extending a guy like Priester would be a major gamble.  We have to see how he bounces back after a lost injured season.  Hopefully we learned a lesson form the Yelich extension when he had that severe knee injury that we ignored.  I doubt we extend multiple outfielders (Adamczewski and Payne) due to the fact we have already extended Chourio and Lara.

  • Like 1
"I'm sick of runnin' from these wimps!" Ajax - The WARRIORS
Community Moderator
Posted
52 minutes ago, TURBO said:

1.  There will be nothing available below that 100 million mark you mention.  To offer him any less will be disrespectful.  My guess is he will want a 5-6 year deal, probably around 125-150 million.

Yeah, there is no way Contreras is signing a 3 year deal. Think about it from his perspective, why in the world would he? Other teams will offer him more for sure.

  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, Team Canada said:

Yeah, there is no way Contreras is signing a 3 year deal. Think about it from his perspective, why in the world would he? Other teams will offer him more for sure.

Add 4/100 extension to his current deal, with an option for a fifth year, and a $10 million buyout.  That would make the deal either 5/124.5 in total or 6/139.5

I think j that would be fair to both sides.

at 5/124.5, William sets a new AAV record for catchers.

that final year (year 6) would most likely not be exercised…  this would give us 3 years with Bill at catcher, and allows him to continue to be the leader of our young pitching stuff during this next 3-5 year window

 

Verified Member
Posted
3 hours ago, TURBO said:

You simply can't extend all those guys, and extending a guy like Priester would be a major gamble. 

Right. I was just saying we need to hunt for young, controllable value. Maybe Henderson. These were a list of targets

Posted

I don't think the Brewers are interested in signing Made or any one still in the minors until the lockout is over.  That would force them to be placed on the 40 man roster.

Posted
44 minutes ago, sdbrewfan said:

I don't think the Brewers are interested in signing Made or any one still in the minors until the lockout is over.  That would force them to be placed on the 40 man roster.

I’m one of those who mentioned a made extension. 
 

I don’t think the brewers will do anything notable before the lock out either way. Just the stuff they have to do like resolve the Bauers QO, tender/non tender decisions, and rule 5 protection. 
 

id clarify for my own list specifically though, that I don’t care whether a made extension happens before opening day or not. If it happens along the same time line as Pratt/Lara that’s fine with me too, but a pre-debut extension is what I’m asking for (or a Konnor griffin style deal where he’s extended shortly after his debut)

Posted

Biggest offseason priority in my mind is to not let sentimentality get in the way of continuing to operate the team in the best/most efficient manner even if it means making move/moves that aren't super popular with the fanbase in the moment.

  • Like 1
Posted
16 hours ago, KCBrewerfan34 said:

Giving pitchers long term deals is just not great business, especially for small market teams. 

The one time they did it recently things didn't look good for a while and then they won the World Series. The Brewers don't sign longer term extensions with young pitchers often but pick their spots and has worked out in the most recent past with Gallardo, Peralta and Ashby.

Posted

Getting a #2/3 pitcher should be the top priority. Probably has to be in a major trade, but certainly doable given the Brewers' farm system. Miz/Henderson/trade/Gasser with plenty of options for the #5 spot. The pen looks good and no need to add to what's already there.  Megil/Ashby/Uribe/Hall/Patrick/Drohan/re-sign Romero/#6 starter.

Extend Contrares: 4/$100M with a 5th year on mutual option. 

I just hope the League and players' union can come to terms and there is baseball in 2027!

  • Like 1
  • Love 1
Posted
1 hour ago, wntrtxn21 said:

Getting a #2/3 pitcher should be the top priority. Probably has to be in a major trade, but certainly doable given the Brewers' farm system. Miz/Henderson/trade/Gasser with plenty of options for the #5 spot. The pen looks good and no need to add to what's already there.  Megil/Ashby/Uribe/Hall/Patrick/Drohan/re-sign Romero/#6 starter.

Extend Contrares: 4/$100M with a 5th year on mutual option. 

I just hope the League and players' union can come to terms and there is baseball in 2027!

What about Priester, Harrison, and Sproat?

all had struggles at different times, but Priester looked great last year and Harrison looked awesome in the first half, while Sproat has the measurables and just needs to put it together.

  • Like 1
Posted
15 hours ago, TwinsBrewersWorldSeries said:

What about Priester, Harrison, and Sproat?

all had struggles at different times, but Priester looked great last year and Harrison looked awesome in the first half, while Sproat has the measurables and just needs to put it together.

I see all of them as being a #5/long man in the pen types, not top of the order pitchers. IF Harrison can get back to the form he had at home the first half of the year, he would be a possibility. However his later year struggles have me very concerned going into next year. 

Verified Member
Posted
18 hours ago, wntrtxn21 said:

Extend Contrares: 4/$100M with a 5th year on mutual option. 

 

He won't sign for less than 5 years at 125 million.  That probably doesn't get it done either.  My guess is he will be looking for 6 years, at least 150 million.

If we could get him for 4/100M, that is a no-brainer, but I just don't see him signing that deal.

"I'm sick of runnin' from these wimps!" Ajax - The WARRIORS
Posted

A lot depends on the holdout/bargaining, I think if a floor does get put in at say $180 I think the #1 priority is re-thinking how we spend money. Adding $50 or million to the salary for 2028 is a big chunk and we need to find a way to still build a roster the Brewer way but with a little more money. I still would pay William long term, with catchers I think that is a losing bet (I would make a 3 year offer, but not much more). If things do go through with a floor for 2028 here is my offseason priorities.

1)Extensions

I would probably look at Turang, Misi, Henderson, Uribe, and Made for extensions. If the league makes a max of 6 year extensions Turang would be a great candidate, we could give him a bigger signing bonus and some more money the next 2/3 years to save money later. I think Misi would be tough to find a deal, but I do think it could be done. 

2) Pitching

Arnold will add a couple arms and at this point I am not really worried about who or how. I could see them spending a little prospect capital on Sandy Alcantara or Joe Ryan with the 'ship in our pocket. I could see us getting a decent free agent arm. I could also see us trade for a couple young undervalued arms like the past few years. I could see us doing one of each and adding a bunch of interesting arm talent with the offense not needing anything.

 

Posted
On 11/8/2026 at 9:26 AM, Mr Southpaw said:

1. Sign Sir William   3 years/$75 mill with an additional 4th year with a team option at $25 mill with a team with a $5 mill buyout.  Either 3/75+5 or 4/100.

2. Extend Made. Switch hitting middle infielder that can run and built like a linebacker don't come around very often.

3. Listen to offers on our other talents.  Andrew Vaughn (assuming Jake Bauer stays), Garrett Mitchell, Sal Frelick, Joey Ortiz can all go, but only for an great deal. 

I think our pitching will work itself out with Priester and Zerpa coming back and Sproats and Drohan improving with age.  We also know that Harrison can pitch well, we just need to get him over the line. Mis,Henderson and Gasser are a good 1,2,3 Priester at 4 and Harrison at 5.  Maybe Woody on a cheap contract and limit his pitch count until September.

I am revising my 3 just a little bit

1. Sign Sir William!   3 years/$90 mill with an additional 4th year with a team option at $30 mill with a team with a $5 mill buyout.  Either 3/90+5 or 4/120.  With Bauer not accepting, we have the money this year and Yeli will be done in two.  They can get it done!  If not pay him the $16 million and do the QO and get another 1st round pick.

If that contract doesn't happen, go get your catcher of the future. My choice is Caden Bodine from Tampa Bay (in another thread I suggested Andrew Fischer and Jett Williams for Tampa Bays Rays Caden Bodine C and Brody Hopkins RHP) a switch hitting catcher who can do it all.  

2. Extend Made. Switch hitting middle infielder that can run and built like a linebacker don't come around very often.  When he is ready early to mid summer, Joey or Hammy become expendable

3. Listen to offers on our other talents.  Garrett Mitchell, Sal Frelick, Joey Ortiz and Hammy can all go, but only for an great deal.  I would even deal Vaughn if the club thinks Adams is ready.

I think our pitching will work itself out with Priester and Zerpa coming back and Sproats and Drohan improving with age.  We also know that Harrison can pitch well, we just need to get him over the line. Mis, Henderson and Gasser are a good 1,2,3 Priester at 4 and Harrison at 5.  Maybe Woody on a cheap contract and limit his pitch count until September. Closers Ashby, Uribe, Megill, and Woody! One last thing...maybe sign Tylor Megill.

Posted

The minor league succession plan is incredible to see. Almost everyone has their backup in place and on time.

Wagoner shoves Uribe who pushes out Megill. Made in for Turang. Fischer/Jett in at 3b. Adamczewski and Payne for Mitchell/Frelick. Burke/Adams for Vaughn, etc

The spots I am least comfortable with re: succession right now would be Quero at C and then the starting pitching depth that is 2ish years away.

So answering the offseason priorities question (and moving beyond MLB things like adding another bullpen arm, a Miley/Quintana type starter, and perusing the market to see if we can do better than the Vaughn/platoon bat currently at 1B)... I would say whichever of our guys are on the trading block (Megill or Patrick or Frelick or Jett or whomever...) ... the return should be prioritizing a MiLB catcher or AA level starting pitching that can get plugged in.

Posted

My priorities would be:

1.   Take care of the front office, development, scouting personnel.  Give them raises, title upgrades, etc - whatever to keep as many folks as possible.  Some have already left and you can't/ don't want to stop people from progressing their careers if available but investing there will keep us competitive for cheaper and longer than any FA signing or extension.  

2.  Extend William Contreras.  His contract can replace Yelich's contract in a couple years.  He's the heart and soul of this team, worked with all the pitchers, he's still young enough.  There's the process the Brewers have adopted, and it's great but sometimes there are exceptions.  I think William qualifies as an exception.  

3. Use some of that prospect capital and trade for a high end starting pitcher.  While they look like they have all the SP spots covered on paper, realistically not everyone will perform as hoped.  They're still pretty young and inexperienced; there are still some growing pains and challenges ahead, imo.  Also, covers for potential injuries.  Ryan or Detmers maybe?  

This franchise is in a place, obviously that they have never been.  They have such a legit chance to run it back with almost the same group locked up for the next few years.  It's crazy to think about where they're at with the current roster and arguably the top farm system along with the #1 prospect in Made still to come.  

Posted

1.  Don't do anything stupid or impulsive.  I get this is obvious, but I really think the Brewers have much more to lose from making moves this offseason than they have to gain.  They're returning almost everyone from a championship team.  Most of the key guys are under 30.  Almost no one (with Miz the obvious exception) put up numbers that seem unrepeatable.  The team is in great shape.

2.  Extend Made (when it makes sense to do so given the lockout).

3.  Get the best return possible for Megill.

4.  Figure out 1b.  I'm all for rolling with Vaughn, getting Yelich a few games over there, and hoping that Burke or Adams forces their way into the picture.

5.  Figure out roles for the pitchers we have and add a couple of undervalued bullpen arms.  I really don't get the eagerness to trade for an established starter.  Here's our SP depth chart IMHO:

Miz

Henderson

Gasser

Harrison

Priester

Drohan

Hardin

Crow

That's assuming Ashby and Patrick stay in the pen and Sproat joins them.  I'm pretty happy with that group.  The cost of getting someone who has proved he's a better MLB starter than Priester, let alone anyone above him, would be astronomical.  I'd say the smartest move the Brewers made this year was refusing to include Henderson in a Skubal package.  If anything, as others have suggested, go out and make another Durbin trade.  Find guys whose names we don't know yet and whom our pitching machine can get the most out of.

Pen looks like:

Uribe

Ashby

Hall

Patrick

Wagoner

Anderson

Walker

Plus maybe Sproat, Gordon, and whoever misses out on the rotation (Drohan?).  I wouldn't mind a couple more intriguing names for that list -- but don't pay a premium for a reliever.  Ever.

 

Posted

I'd lean towards just keeping Megill.  Not to say they haven't done ok with what they got back, but I think most of our reactions to the returns we got for Hader/Williams was underwhelmed.  Those two were considered top 2-3ish in the league when they were traded and they were much younger, so the acquiring team was at least hoping to keep/extend. And just in general the younger the better.  Megill is much older and considered more in the 2nd tier of top closers (though I'd say he's a bit underrated) rather than one of the top top guys. My guess is that we wouldn't get a good enough haul to not want to just roll it back and go for the repeat.    Saving that 15ish mil by keeping Vaughn instead of Bauers should help afford it. 

You know we'd just be looking for another reliever at the deadline anyway, so might as well just keep the guy you got. 

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...