Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Verified Member
Posted

OFF:

P Brandon Woodruff, contract expired

P Dustin May, contract expired

P JoJo Romero, contract expired

1B Jake Bauers, contract expired

C Gary Sanchez, contract expired

P Antonio Senzatela, contract expired

OF Akil Baddoo, waived

P Bryse Wilson, outrighted

P Jared Koenign, outrighted

 

The 40-man roster is at 30.

 

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted
4 hours ago, DonBarclay said:

40 man roster is full. 

I have to admit, this one is perplexing to me. Why fill the 40 man now? Are those guys THAT important you can't lose them?  I understand maybe 3 of them, but 6?? I get it, plenty of offseason left, but I would have much rather seen a few spots left open for potential future additions

Posted
6 minutes ago, ImissDougMelvin said:

I have to admit, this one is perplexing to me. Why fill the 40 man now? Are those guys THAT important you can't lose them?  I understand maybe 3 of them, but 6?? I get it, plenty of offseason left, but I would have much rather seen a few spots left open for potential future additions

They can easily remove someone if we acquire someone better, correct?

  • Like 1
Posted
11 hours ago, Jimbo said:

ON:

P Ryan Walker, acquired

 

The 40-man roster is at 31.

How did we go from 31 to full by adding 6 players? I'm missing something.

Posted
1 minute ago, MoreTrife said:

How did we go from 31 to full by adding 6 players? I'm missing something.

Guessing Jimbo still has the 60 Day IL players as not on the 40. They had three of them (Fitzpatrick, Priester, Zerpa)

  • Like 2
Posted

Generally speaking, what was the reason to add them now?  Is there even going to be a rule 5 draft and were these guys at the point where you could lose them in it?    Quick thing I thought was those are some good young guys you'd prefer to keep playing in a lockout. But there has to be some logistical reason why they did it

Posted

Simply put, in case there is a Rule 5 draft they did not want to lose these players for a small amount of cash. They can always create some openings down the road (Naylor, Black and Anderson etc….)

Posted
9 hours ago, ImissDougMelvin said:

I have to admit, this one is perplexing to me. Why fill the 40 man now? Are those guys THAT important you can't lose them?  I understand maybe 3 of them, but 6?? I get it, plenty of offseason left, but I would have much rather seen a few spots left open for potential future additions

I think Adams, Wagoner, Jett Wiliams was obvious. I think Wood was a logical addition. I would have gone with Witchrowski over Kuehner, but either way. And O'Rae has played VERY well. He had a down year in '25 IIRC, injuries, but... he's a pretty talented and versatile utility player. 

I don't think any of these are surprising. And it's not like you have to keep all these players all year and can't sign anyone. You can also remove Stallings for example. 

Not a big deal to be at 40 going into the lockout. 

.

Posted

There was at least some downside to adding these guys to the 40. As I understand it, when a lockout occurs, they will not be able to continue training/playing, whereas those minor leaguers not yet on the 40, will be able to.  But I agree with their decision that leaving these guys off and then hoping a Rule 5 draft does not happen was far more risky than potentially forfeiting a couple months of their development.

Posted
9 minutes ago, titanrick said:

There was at least some downside to adding these guys to the 40. As I understand it, when a lockout occurs, they will not be able to continue training/playing, whereas those minor leaguers not yet on the 40, will be able to.  But I agree with their decision that leaving these guys off and then hoping a Rule 5 draft does not happen was far more risky than potentially forfeiting a couple months of their development.

I'm sure the convos on this topic at headquarters were 'spirited' because this is an odd offseason like you mentioned. Don't add them and lose them potentially. Add them and we just added 6 guys who now can't play baseball until a labor deal is made.

Does anyone know how the salary situation works for these guys now (and I guess any guy on the 40 man without a major league deal)? They are on the 40man roster so they will be a part of the lockout and can't play - but they do not have a guaranteed salary as far as I'm aware? So if the full season were to be missed hypothetically - did these 6 guys just lose a year of minor league pay?

Posted

Toss out the probable lockout. If this were a typical year, how long would they have to stay on the 40 in order to be protected from the Dec Rule 5 Draft? If the point is to protect them from being poached, can they be removed from the 40 a day after the Rule 5 Draft and and still be protected? Can teams just play nudge nudge wink wink with this? 

Posted
24 minutes ago, Turning2 said:

Toss out the probable lockout. If this were a typical year, how long would they have to stay on the 40 in order to be protected from the Dec Rule 5 Draft? If the point is to protect them from being poached, can they be removed from the 40 a day after the Rule 5 Draft and and still be protected? Can teams just play nudge nudge wink wink with this? 

They’re significantly more likely to be lost to another team if you try to drop them from the 40 man roster after the Rule 5 draft. To remove them, they’d need to be DFA’d and exposed to waivers. If claimed, they’d simply need to be on that teams 40 man vs having to actually be on the 26 man active roster as a Rule 5 draft pick. 

  • Like 2
Posted
21 minutes ago, Turning2 said:

Toss out the probable lockout. If this were a typical year, how long would they have to stay on the 40 in order to be protected from the Dec Rule 5 Draft? If the point is to protect them from being poached, can they be removed from the 40 a day after the Rule 5 Draft and and still be protected? Can teams just play nudge nudge wink wink with this? 

I was wondering about that also.  I think to remove someone from the 40 man list, requires them to clear waivers (DFA) before you can return them to your minor league system (not sure if that's the right terminology).

I think it also starts the clock on options (3 years) in which you need to promote them to the 26 man roster or DFA them.

Sound about right?

Posted
25 minutes ago, Turning2 said:

Toss out the probable lockout. If this were a typical year, how long would they have to stay on the 40 in order to be protected from the Dec Rule 5 Draft? If the point is to protect them from being poached, can they be removed from the 40 a day after the Rule 5 Draft and and still be protected? Can teams just play nudge nudge wink wink with this? 

It's actually better for the claiming team to wait for the player to be DFA'd off a team's 40 man roster than to draft them in the rule 5.  They would not have to follow the rule 5 draft rules of keeping the player on the major league roster for the entire season.  they could simply claim them and option them to the minors right away.  The player would only be tying up a 40 man spot.

Posted
57 minutes ago, DonBarclay said:

They’re significantly more likely to be lost to another team if you try to drop them from the 40 man roster after the Rule 5 draft. To remove them, they’d need to be DFA’d and exposed to waivers. If claimed, they’d simply need to be on that teams 40 man vs having to actually be on the 26 man active roster as a Rule 5 draft pick. 

Thanks. I knew there had to be a reason. Not sure of the rationale behind it though.  Doesn't make sense that a team essentially is forced to cut a guy they have the rights to if they shuffle the 40. Maybe it's part of the previous CBA to give players more pathways for advancement. 

Posted

Is there a list of players that we did NOT protect that could potentially be lost to the Rule 5 draft?

"I'm sick of runnin' from these wimps!" Ajax - The WARRIORS
Posted
3 hours ago, DonBarclay said:

 

I dont see too much there to be worried about.  Maybe a bad team takes a chance on Brock Wilken's power?  Doubt it, IDK, obviously.  Maybe Boeve?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...