Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Prospect voting complete, thank you for voting!

Seth Stohs
 Share
Seth Stohs Draft Eligible

Seth Stohs

Site Manager
Posted
Posted

Thank you so much to all of you who voted. Incredibly impressed by the tremendous turnout this round. We'll be taking this information and applying it to the prospect list in the coming days. Keep an eye out for it!  

The ranking you see below is from the Community. It will be consolidated with the votes of the Brewer Fanatic minor league writers that voted for the official rankings that you'll see on the Prospect List. 

Ranked Prospects

  • Like 1

Recommended Posts

Branyanisthegoat Prep Ball

Branyanisthegoat

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jacob Misiorowski
  2. Jeferson Quero
  3. Brock Wilken
  4. Robert Gasser
  5. Tyler Black
  6. Luis Lara
  7. Mike Boeve
  8. Yophery Rodriguez
  9. Brett Wichrowski
  10. Cooper Pratt
  11. Carlos F Rodriguez
  12. Josh Knoth
  13. Logan Henderson
  14. Eric Bitonti
  15. Eric Brown Jr
  16. Bradley Blalock
  17. Tyler Woessner
  18. Juan Baez
  19. Gregory Barrios
  20. Dylan O'Rae

I really, really like Wichrowski, big velo strike, think the they struck/created gold again. Mis and Wich the rowski brothers would be a fun TOR pair.

Generally not a big fan of ranking 1B or all bat guys high, as the floor is just so low, and you reeeaallly have to hit to be a high war guy, so lower on Black somewhat, and just about out on Luke Adams.

jay87shot ACL Brewers

jay87shot

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jeferson Quero
  2. Jacob Misiorowski
  3. Tyler Black
  4. Brock Wilken
  5. Robert Gasser
  6. Luis Lara
  7. Yophery Rodriguez
  8. Mike Boeve
  9. Josh Knoth
  10. Cooper Pratt
  11. Carlos F Rodriguez
  12. Eric Brown Jr
  13. Luke Adams
  14. Juan Baez
  15. Daniel Guilarte
  16. Dylan O'Rae
  17. Gregory Barrios
  18. Eric Bitonti
  19. Logan Henderson
  20. Manuel Rodriguez

Quero falls to #3 with the injury and Misi/Black playing well. I had a tough time deciding where to put Boeve, before or after our younger top prospect, so I put him in the middle. Car Rod and EBJ fall, and from 13-18 I have the young talented IF. I only added Barrios and Rodriguez but there where a bunch of options. Lestson, Hall, Wichrowski, Herrera, and few other could make a claim along with some older prospects like Blalock, Wood, Clarke, Dunn, Myers etc.

biedergb ACL Brewers

biedergb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jacob Misiorowski
    Highest talent, at AA, but could rank anywhere from 1-3
  2. Jeferson Quero
    Would be #1 for sure if healthy.
  3. Brock Wilken
    Potential is there, and could be #1 by end of the season.
  4. Tyler Black
    Professional hitter. Needs to adjust to MLB pitching. Lack of clear defense has always held him back, but clearly a top 5 prospect given age/level/track history
  5. Robert Gasser
    Default top starting pitching prospect, and may be off this list sometime this year if he pitches more in the bigs, but could be a chance at #1 prospect status if he doesn't get enough innings in the Show.
  6. Carlos F Rodriguez
    Could rise big by the end of the end or fall big - is April CRod what to expect, or the 2 starts in May more the real him?
  7. Mike Boeve
    He is hitting and as long as he does he will rise.
  8. Luis Lara
    So young for his level
  9. Cooper Pratt
  10. Juan Baez
    Hits at every level, and still young. Overlooked a bit in a deep system?
  11. Josh Knoth
  12. Yophery Rodriguez
    Star potential, but looks overmatched some nights. All to be expected for an 18 year old in A ball. Hopeful he can learn from his A ball experience. So much variability - could push for the top spot by next year if he puts it all together.
  13. Dylan O'Rae
    Whirling dervish of a player. Gets walks, BHP, slap hits, steals bases, scores from first. A little engine that drives the offense. Lack of power and true defensive home will keep him out of the top 5-10 discussion.
  14. Bradley Blalock
    Nice start to the year. Needs to stay healthy and hopefully move up to AAA to keep his prospect status.
  15. Brett Wichrowski
    Out of nowhere to the top 15-20 discussion. Already in AA less than a year after being drafted.
  16. Luke Adams
    Solid plate discipline. Average is not there, power still is there. Probably a 1B once he moves up. Still so young so still a lot of potential movement up or down the charts.
  17. Logan Henderson
    Make or break year as a prospect. Dominated low A last year, so high A will be a real test, and if he can make it up to AA he moves up the list.
  18. Eric Bitonti
    Still in rookie ball, it's his potential as a power hitter that is the key. Outside of Wilken he is the only true slugger on the list. He can rise, or completely drop off based upon his season this year and next at the plate.
  19. Wes Clarke
    AA/AAA, hits and slugs, can play 1B/DH and catch. Not a true "prospect" but hard to keep him off the list at this time. But clearly his "prospect" days are numbered either due to progression of others, or maybe because he finds the bigs this year or early next.
  20. Eric Brown Jr
    Elite defender. Feels like he has been here for years, but only drafted in 2022. Frelick, Black, Wilken, Boeve ascensions make him seem like a laggard, but he has a year or so to prove it. Defense is MLB ready.

Top 5 are set but interchangeable. Quero missing a year and injury keeps him off the top spot, but would be otherwise. Boeve a big jump. Wichrowski has to join the list.

I have Brown falling, but staying on the top 20 since he is at AA and has elite defense.

Baez is only 6 months older than Y. Rodriguez, and is a hitting machine. Probably a decent IF for a defensive home.

I want to add M. Rodriguez, Y. Herrera among other young pitchers, but still too early on to move them too high. Henderson and Blalock swap spots for me, with Blalock arrow up, and Henderson down until he gets back into action.

This is tough. I like Wes Clarke, and as a hitting/slugging AA/AAA prospect (albeit older for his levels) gave him the spot, but both he and Brown will drop off is the younger players start to perform, and after the draft. Unless EBJ starts to hit, c'mon Eric, find that college ball swing of yours and start to hit the cover off the ball.

AJOHNSON104 College Ball

AJOHNSON104

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jacob Misiorowski
  2. Tyler Black
  3. Robert Gasser
    Might be a stretch her, but I put more value on guys who appear closer to MLB ready
  4. Brock Wilken
  5. Carlos F Rodriguez
  6. Cooper Pratt
  7. Luis Lara
  8. Jeferson Quero
    shoulder injuries not good for anyone, let alone a catcher
  9. Mike Boeve
    great contact and plate discipline. Want to see a little more power
  10. Yophery Rodriguez
  11. Eric Brown Jr
  12. Josh Knoth
  13. Luke Adams
  14. Bradley Blalock
  15. Juan Baez
  16. Eric Bitonti
  17. Daniel Guilarte
  18. Logan Henderson
  19. Dylan O'Rae
  20. Tyler Woessner
sveumrules Milwaukee Brewers

sveumrules

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jacob Misiorowski
    Highest upside in the system.
  2. Robert Gasser
    Helping the MLB rotation now.
  3. Tyler Black
    Good 1B/DH insurance policy.
  4. Jeferson Quero
    Contender for #1 if not for injury.
  5. Brock Wilken
    Love how much power he generates from such a simple set up.
  6. Mike Boeve
    Can't imagine too many guys have two different minor league stops with .500 batting averages.
  7. Yophery Rodriguez
    Highest upside of the hitters yet to reach AA.
  8. Luis Lara
    Holding his own as one of only three teenage hitters in the Midwest League.
  9. Cooper Pratt
    Solid start to full season ball.
  10. Josh Knoth
    Stuff has lived up to the billing.
  11. Eric Brown Jr
    I still believe.
  12. Carlos F Rodriguez
    Put together his two best starts of the year (11 IP | 2 ER | 15 K | 2 BB) leading up to voting, hopefully a sign he is starting to figure things out at the AAA level.
  13. Bradley Blalock
    Getting good results in his first exposure to AA.
  14. Tyler Woessner
    Dominated AA, but got bombed in his first two AAA starts.
  15. Logan Henderson
    Just needs to stay healthy and stack innings the rest of the summer.
  16. Gregory Barrios
    Hot start at A+ has pushed him to the top of the second tier of hitters yet to reach AA for me.
  17. Luke Adams
    Intriguing mix of OBP, power and speed (low batting average notwithstanding)
  18. Dylan O'Rae
    Just keeps on getting on base and stealing bags.
  19. Juan Baez
    Just keeps on hitting (and getting caught stealing bags)
  20. Craig Yoho
    YO-HO!! YO-HO!! YO-HO!!
  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

Become a Caretaker

  • Member Statistics

    6,259
    Total Members
    12,207
    Most Online
    Kevin OBrien
    Newest Member
    Kevin OBrien
    Joined
×
×
  • Create New...