Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

June prospect voting results

Brock Beauchamp
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 71
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

biedergb
biedergb

If Bieder is referring to me, then whoa, that is some incredibly illustrious company that I don't deserve to be in, but if not (see my post a month ago when I thought I was the Greg that Joseph refere

Austin Tatious
Austin Tatious

I feel like Spencer, Joseph and Bieder are the answer key and I check my work against them.  

Joseph Zarr
Joseph Zarr

I believe Fangraphs gave me a 10 Grade in 'Process'. It's holding me back. I mean it 'should' be pretty clear by now (?) I'd have Dinges sitting firmly in that Top 5 - for example.

jay87shot ACL Brewers

jay87shot

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jesus Made
  2. Jacob Misiorowski
  3. Luis Pena
  4. Cooper Pratt
  5. Jeferson Quero
  6. Logan Henderson
  7. Luke Adams
  8. Eric Bitonti
  9. Braylon Payne
  10. Bishop Letson
  11. Mike Boeve
  12. Josh Adamczewski
  13. Luis Lara
  14. Bryce Meccage
  15. Marco Dinges
  16. Blake Burke
  17. Carlos F Rodriguez
  18. Craig Yoho
  19. Brock Wilken
  20. Brett Wichrowski

21-30 Gasser, Black, Knoth Crow, Hardin, Hunt, Arienamo, Di Turri, Seigler, EMJ

With time missed I've dropped Gasser, Black, and Knoth off the top 20 even though talent wise they are borderline top 10. 

31-40 Anderson, Fenelon, Antununez, Dorchies, Renz, Dubanewicz, King, Bjorn Johnson

I am just putting all the young teenage talent here, in a month or two it should be more obvious which of these are going to take off.

41-50 Corobo, Encarnacion, Montero, Cornielle, Baez, Birchard, Manny Rodriguez, Kuehner, Travis Smith, Leonard Rijo

More teenagers and a handful of guys who should be in the top 30 but I just pushed back because of all the younger talent.

ecjimg Draft Eligible

ecjimg

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jesus Made
  2. Jacob Misiorowski
  3. Luis Pena
  4. Cooper Pratt
    I really thought he would dominate in AA and be considered for a quick promotion to MLB
  5. Jeferson Quero
  6. Logan Henderson
  7. Brock Wilken
  8. Eric Bitonti
  9. Robert Gasser
  10. Craig Yoho
  11. Mike Boeve
  12. Bishop Letson
  13. Marco Dinges
  14. Braylon Payne
  15. Josh Adamczewski
  16. Luke Adams
  17. Blake Burke
  18. Brett Wichrowski
  19. Luis Lara
  20. Coleman Crow

Brock Wilken is baaaaaaaack!   I said it last month i think, this should be a top 30! (like Baseball America)

I ranked some pitchers lower just because there is such a large injury factor with pitching. It doesnt appear that Tyler Black, Carlos Rodriguez or Ernesto Martinez are in their plans in that others have been promoted instead of them.

  • Like 2
Playing Catch ACL Brewers

Playing Catch

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jacob Misiorowski
  2. Jesus Made
  3. Luis Pena
  4. Cooper Pratt
  5. Jeferson Quero
  6. Logan Henderson
  7. Robert Gasser
  8. Craig Yoho
  9. Marco Dinges
  10. Braylon Payne
  11. Bishop Letson
  12. Luke Adams
  13. Eric Bitonti
  14. Luis Lara
  15. Brock Wilken
  16. Mike Boeve
  17. Jadher Areinamo
  18. Coleman Crow
  19. Bryce Meccage
  20. Josh Adamczewski

For all of their remarkable success in recent seasons, this might be the "best" minor league season I can remember, in terms of prospect performance. Guys are earning their rankings, and pushing for promotion, outside of injury-related performance. Not many guys are struggling. Even a guy like Bitonti (with that tall, angular frame) who is off to a slow start, has a wRC+ of 111.

I'll predict that Yoho and Boeve are the biggest fallers. Dinges and Adamczewski the biggest risers.

  • Love 1
Joseph Zarr Milwaukee Brewers

Joseph Zarr

Brewer Fanatic Contributor
Posted
Posted
  1. Jacob Misiorowski
  2. Jesus Made
  3. Cooper Pratt
  4. Jeferson Quero
  5. Luis Pena
  6. Braylon Payne
  7. Logan Henderson
  8. Robert Gasser
  9. Mike Boeve
  10. Craig Yoho
  11. Tyler Black
  12. Eric Bitonti
  13. Josh Adamczewski
  14. Carlos F Rodriguez
  15. Bishop Letson
  16. Luis Lara
  17. Brock Wilken
  18. Ernesto Martinez
  19. Josh Knoth
  20. Bryce Meccage

Basic entirely unsolicited thoughts about our list of players here:

(1) 2025 Eduardo Garcia - especially given his ability to competently play SS/3B/CF not an easy feat - imho is definitively a more vote-worthy prospect than Guilarte and Hall. 

(2) I don't know why RHP Tyler Woessner is on this list. He hasn't shown anything resembling remotely close to a Top 20 guy for over 1.5 years. He's not even remotely a Top 30 guy from my vantage point.

(3) I think we are seeing 1B/DH Wes Clarke is back to fringe Top 30 guy. He is now only getting spot (and I do mean 'spot') playing time with the addition of savvy vet Bobby Dalbec and EMJ's return from injury. He is now playing essentially 2-to-3 games every six-game set. He continues to strike out at far too many pitches in the zone. Given his age, his limitations, and these flaws I just don't see him as anything other than a fringe 30 guy.

(4) It's very early in the DSL but there are a couple of players who weren't the highly touted we'll want to keep an eye on. INF Leonard Rijo has really impressed early, OF Carlos Done (Injured last season - 2024 signee) has flashed, C Johanderson Tarazona has flashed (albeit in an absurdly small sample size, unfortunately). It's obviously way too early here. Big name signings have gotten off to very pedestrian starts (and that's being quite generous - without Fenelon's early HR you likely wouldn't even notice their collective outputs). And, we know not to over invest in DSL pitching thoughts.

(4) I think if we're going to be putting these older names up here we should very much consider counter-balancing that narrative with some of the extremely young names impressive. I go immediately to the HS pitchers from last year's draft. RHP's Jayden Dubanewicz, Ethan Dorchies, and Hayden Robinson (now that he's back healthy). I would personally be more bullish about including these types of upside unknowns than several of the older names on this list. This may just be me, however.

(5) To that same end, I'd be inclined to want to vote on INF Juan Ortuno, INF Jorge Quintana, OF Jorge Quintana over some of the older names on this list from a purely speculatively upside and youth proposition

(6) INF/OF Luis Lameda, imho, is currently one of the most underrated versatile rapidly maturing and evolving stateside player in my viewing world. This young man moves with agility and athleticism. He is a smooth and graceful athlete. His bat is really intriguing - he has line drive pop in there. He has snuck up into my wheelhouse of players I love to watch perhaps faster than any other player in the stateside ranks in 2025. I have been absurdly pleasantly surprised by what I have seen.

(7) OF Hedbert Perez is stating his case to potentially be in these names by season's end. His minor shoulder injury knocked him back some and he hasn't quite regained that heater he was on. BUT, he has made it known he may belong back in consideration for Top 20 votes here and there.

(8) C Matt Wood is suddenly becoming a name to really pay attention to in Biloxi. Of all things! This could just be a hot stretch - we've seen it time and again in Minor League baseball. But, it could also be the start of something for him. I am merely saying we should continue monitoring his progress down in the Southern League. 

That is all I can think of in this rapid-fire 'over coffee' morning thoughts before I go tend to farm work. Happy voting!

  • Like 1
  • Love 1
MattK College Ball

MattK

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jesus Made
    Left side of the infield player who should be in the majors as early as 2028. Very good batting eye with electric bat will grow into even more power.
  2. Luis Pena
    Left side of the infield player with great hit tool. Could be in the majors as early as 2028.
  3. Jacob Misiorowski
    Floor of a bullpen ace. Still a shot as a starter. If Chris Hook can get him to throw more strikes, ceiling is a #2 starter.
  4. Cooper Pratt
    Floor is a 5-10 year defensive ace at short, good enough to keep Pena & Made off of short. If he can get to some in-game power, may be a multiple time All Star.
  5. Marco Dinges
    Electric bat with some power. If he can catch, will be an All Star.
  6. Josh Adamczewski
    Best current hitter in the system. Hit tool. Current doubles plus power. Good eye. If his back is fine, will be in LF in Milwaukee by 2028 or 9.
  7. Luke Adams
    This year has shown some of what his ceiling can be. If he lets himself be more aggressive in the zone, trusting his swing decisions, first base can be his for years.
  8. Logan Henderson
    Floor as a 4th starter. Will be in the rotation in 2026. Hopefully can keep his fastball high revving enough to limit homers.
  9. Jeferson Quero
    Hard to judge right now. Defensively, he is super rusty after the year out. Gotta think of this as a reset year.
  10. Braylon Payne
    Super young. Super inexperienced. Tremendous tools - at least a 4 tool player who we will see if he can hit enough. Loses some gloss playing daily with Pena & Made. If there was still the short season leagues, he would be ideal.
  11. Brock Wilken
    Seems he can stay at 3B. Will supply power and walks, but the Ks will limit his hit tool enough that once Made & Pena come through the system, he will be in the 1B group, and may not be able to play ahead of the younger Adams.
  12. Craig Yoho
    Has some ability to get whiffs in the majors. Needs to also throw in-zone strikes. His time in the majors will completely rely on that. Could be a key pen member soon, if he can figure that out.
  13. Carlos F Rodriguez
    How hurt is he? Looks that he could be a 4th starter in 2026, but if hurt, that throws that out the window.
  14. Luis Lara
    Has shown some of what his ceiling could be this year. Speed. Excellent D. Some hit with some pop. Needs to climb another level and show more.
  15. Bryce Meccage
    Looks great so far. Good ceiling. Floor depends on the need to get through the next couple of years without getting hurt. About exactly the same as Letson or Manuel Rodriguez or Knoth.
  16. Alexander Cornielle
    Has shown very well at his highest level this year. When the glut of starting pitching ahead of him clears out, he will be in Nashville, and then we will know a lot. Does not seem to have a high ceiling, but a solid floor as a 4th starter (along with 5-6 other guys in the system) is in play.
  17. Coleman Crow
    Has shown very well at his highest level this year. When the glut of starting pitching ahead of him clears out, he will be in Nashville, and then we will know a lot. Does not seem to have a high ceiling, but a solid floor as a 4th starter (along with 5-6 other guys in the system) is in play.
  18. Eric Bitonti
    More real power than likely anyone in the system. Has work to do as he has so much swing and miss. Already at 1B only, so if he is to make the majors, will have to figure that out.
  19. Bishop Letson
    How hurt is he? Looked good through last season, and even better at the beginning of this season. Cannot be determined until he comes back. Maybe not different for Meccage or Knoth or Manuel Rodriguez either; their health will be the key.
  20. Mike Boeve
    Still recovering from injury. This may be a reset year, or he has hit a peak in AA. 2026 will tell all. His swing & miss is quite higher than ever, and his walks/hits are down. Plus in the 1B/DH mix behind Adams & Wilken.

Thanks for letting me pontificate/vent/speculate.  It was fun!  Could have thoughts for a top 30.  :-)

SF70 First Round Pick

SF70

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jesus Made
  2. Luis Pena
  3. Jacob Misiorowski
  4. Cooper Pratt
  5. Jeferson Quero
  6. Marco Dinges
  7. Logan Henderson
  8. Braylon Payne
  9. Robert Gasser
  10. Eric Bitonti
  11. Bishop Letson
  12. Josh Adamczewski
  13. Mike Boeve
  14. Brock Wilken
  15. Luke Adams
  16. Bryce Meccage
  17. Jason Woodward
  18. Brailyn Antunez
  19. Blake Burke
  20. Coleman Crow

Top 10 has so much future impact. 
 

Another draft similar to ‘24 and this will be hands down the best farm system in the game. It might get there without it.

 

This system is really balanced with positional vs pitching. Bodes well in being able to supply the big-club with what it needs to become a powerhouse later this decade.

  • Love 1
Wicki Prep Ball

Wicki

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Luis Pena
  2. Jacob Misiorowski
  3. Jesus Made
  4. Logan Henderson
  5. Cooper Pratt
  6. Jeferson Quero
  7. Luke Adams
  8. Marco Dinges
  9. Robert Gasser
  10. Brock Wilken
  11. Eric Bitonti
  12. Braylon Payne
  13. Mike Boeve
  14. Bishop Letson
  15. Luis Lara
  16. Coleman Crow
  17. Craig Yoho
  18. Bryce Meccage
  19. Blake Burke
  20. Tyson Hardin

Higher in Pena than Made, Henderson proved at the majors he can be extremely effective. Worry about no great 3rd pitch yet. Of the infield guys at AA, I see Pratt being another version of turang and of the other 3 I’m the highest on Luke Adams and love how he has performed his best of any year in the minors at AA. Needs to get a little more agressive, but think his floor is the highest of him, wilken and Boeve. Also have become a big fan of dinges and reports are his defense is coming along well, which was his biggest red flag. Think there’s a lot of young pitchers at every level that have high potential as well including Meccage, Hardin, Crow and Letson. Can’t wait to see how they all develop.

  • Love 1
sveumrules Milwaukee Brewers

sveumrules

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
  1. Jacob Misiorowski
  2. Jesus Made
  3. Luis Pena
  4. Logan Henderson
  5. Jeferson Quero
  6. Cooper Pratt
  7. Marco Dinges
  8. Luke Adams
  9. Robert Gasser
  10. Coleman Crow
  11. Bishop Letson
  12. Bryce Meccage
  13. Josh Knoth
  14. Craig Yoho
  15. Tyson Hardin
  16. Braylon Payne
  17. Josh Adamczewski
  18. Ernesto Martinez
  19. Blake Burke
  20. Bjorn Johnson
    Easily a dozen legit options for this last spot, but went with Bjorn because his 2.21 FIP is currently 4th in the Brewers system behind Crow (1.75), Hardin (1.89), and Letson (2.14).
  • Love 1
Spencer Michaelis First Round Pick

Spencer Michaelis

Brewer Fanatic Contributor
Posted
Posted
  1. Jesus Made
  2. Jacob Misiorowski
  3. Luis Pena
  4. Jeferson Quero
  5. Cooper Pratt
  6. Logan Henderson
  7. Bishop Letson
  8. Braylon Payne
  9. Robert Gasser
  10. Craig Yoho
  11. Bryce Meccage
  12. Marco Dinges
  13. Tyson Hardin
  14. Brailyn Antunez
  15. Brock Wilken
  16. Luke Adams
  17. Mike Boeve
  18. Josh Adamczewski
  19. Coleman Crow
  20. Eric Bitonti

Don't have time to add notes for my T20, but in honor of Toby, AKA "And That" from the old days on Fanatic, here are my current tiers through 35 OFP. I view the tiers as much more important than the rankings, especially once you get outside of the Top 10-20.

On my personal spreadsheet, 30+ through 40 tiers have quite a bit of shuffling done throughout the year, but it's harder to move into the 40+ tier and higher.

60 OFP: Made, Misiorowski
55 OFP: Peña
50 OFP: Quero, Pratt
45+ OFP: Henderson through Meccage
45 OFP: Dinges through Bitonti

40+ OFP
21        Luis Lara        OF
22        Kenny Fenelon        OF
23        K.C. Hunt        RHP
24        Blake Burke        1B
25        Josh Knoth        RHP
26        Brett Wichrowski        RHP
27        Jadher Areinamo        UTIL
28        Anthony Seigler        UTIL
29        Ernesto Martinez        1B

40 OFP
30        Carlos Rodriguez        RHP
31        Jose Anderson        OF
32        Tyler Black        UTIL
33        Yorman Galindez        RHP
34        Jorge Quintana        SS
35        Ethan Dorchies        RHP
36        Tyler Renz        RHP
37        Jason Woodward        RHP
38        Manuel Rodriguez        RHP
39        Luis Corobo        C
40        Yeuri Ramirez        RHP
41        Alexander Cornielle        RHP
42        Tate Kuehner        LHP

35+ OFP
43        Jack Hostetler        RHP
44        Juan Baez        UTIL
45        Jaron Deberry        RHP
46        Handelfry Encarnacion        OF
47        Cristopher Acosta        SS
48        Hayden Robinson        RHP
49        Alexander Frias        OF
50        Gerlyn Payano        OF
51         Ryan Birchard        RHP
52        Joseph Broughton        LHP
53        Melvin Hernandez        RHP
54        Juan Ortuno        UTIL
55        Filippo Di Turi        SS
56        Matthew Wood        C
57        Eduardo Garcia        UTIL
58        Jayden Dubanewicz        RHP
59        Luiyin Alastre        SS
60        Will Childers        RHP
61        Travis Smith        RHP
62        Sam Garcia        LHP
63        Bjorn Johnson        LHP
64        Quinton Low        Two Way
65        Dylan O'Rae        UTIL
66        Wande Torres        LHP
67        Bryan Rivera        RHP
68        Diustin Mayorquin        RHP

35 OFP
69        Enniel Cortez        RHP
70        Tyler Rodriguez        SS
71        Justin Yeager        RHP
72        Eric Brown        SS
73        Luis Aguayo        RHP
74        Cristian Montilla        SS
75        Brian Fitzpatrick        LHP
76        Eryks Rivero        OF
77        Kay-Lan Nicasia        OF
78        Luis Castillo        OF
79        Daniel Corniel        RHP
80        Miqueas Mercedes        RHP
81        Chase Costello        RHP
82        Aidan Maldonado        RHP
83        Tyler Bryant        RHP
84        Hedbert Perez        OF
85        Yerlin Rodriguez        RHP
86        Luis Lameda        UTIL
87        Demetrio Nadal        UTIL
88        Mark Manfredi        LHP
89        Ayendy Bravo        RHP
90        Isais Chavez        C
91         Edgardo Ordonez        C
92        Tayden Hall        1B
93        Easton McGee        RHP
94        Frederi Montero        3B
95        Griffin Tobias        RHP
96        Moises Polanco        2B
97        Carlos Carra        RHP
98        Anthony Flores        LHP
99        Leonard Rijo        SS
100        Zach Peek        RHP
101        Tanner Gillis        RHP
102        Jesus Flores        RHP
103        Chandler Welch        RHP
104        Cameron Wagoner        RHP
105        Frandy Lafond        OF
106        Nick Merkel        RHP
107        Wenderlyn King        RHP
108        Enrique Velasquez        RHP
109        Enderson Mercado        LHP
110        Raynel Delgado        2B
111         Eric Prado        RHP
112        Dikember Sanchez        RHP
113        Merwin Manrique        RHP
114        Blake Holub        RHP
115        Gustavo Garcia        RHP

 
 
  • Like 2
  • Love 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

Become a Caretaker

  • Member Statistics

    6,272
    Total Members
    12,207
    Most Online
    Berghs4
    Newest Member
    Berghs4
    Joined
×
×
  • Create New...